Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 389
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
He remains an option to return to the 25-man roster. Don't want that.

 

If it's only as an injury replacement I'm fine with that. There are worse scenarios than having to call up a great defender, at least he provides something. Like I said though, more than fine with moving him too.

Posted
If it's only as an injury replacement I'm fine with that. There are worse scenarios than having to call up a great defender, at least he provides something. Like I said though, more than fine with moving him too.

 

I just feel like I could be a better and happier person if I never have to watch Goins swing a bat again. Or reading Gruber post how about that Goins kid when he does something slightly helpful.

Posted
How tits would this be?

 

LF Fowler

3B Donaldson

SS Tulowitzki

1B Encarnacion

RF Pearce

DH Morales

C Martin

2B Travis

CF Pillar

 

That's bitchin'

 

But I can't see us keeping Edwin AND signing Fowler

Community Moderator
Posted

 

Paul Kinzer can f*** right off at this point.

Posted
How tits would this be?

 

LF Fowler

3B Donaldson

SS Tulowitzki

1B Encarnacion

RF Pearce

DH Morales

C Martin

2B Travis

CF Pillar

 

Jays are worse than I thought. Glad we dont have to deal with EE and Bau anymore.

Posted

Vs RHP

RF Fowler

SS Tulo

3B Donaldson

DH Morales

LF Pearce

C Martin

2B Travis

1B Smoak

CF Pillar

 

Vs LHP

RF Fowler

SS Tulo

3B Donaldson

DH Morales

1B Pearce

C Martin

LF Upton

CF Pillar

 

In my opinion we have the potential to put together some damn good lineups, but I'm 100% sold that we need to sign Fowler to lead off.

Posted

Back peddling?

 

 

 

Posted
We'll see. Things can change quickly. EE can still probably get his 80 mil IMO.

 

Possibly, but with destinations dwindling and the pick attached, I would guess that's unlikely at this point.

 

I know it's hard to put oneself in Edwin's shoes, but turning down $80 million to play in a city that you love; where you have tremendous fan support; and where the team has been knocking on the door the last couple of seasons; it just seems like a regrettable misstep.

Posted
What if Bats came back & played 1B? (for Dinger's fantasy line up that is)

 

I'd take Bautista for 1B on a 1 year deal in a heartbeat

Posted (edited)

Morales is full time DH

 

Can Pearce fill a whole season playing OF?

 

That's the only way to make sure he gets full playing time if we get Edwin back too

 

Is Pearce as bad in the OF as Bautista for example?

Edited by G-Snarls
Posted
Jays are worse than I thought. Glad we dont have to deal with EE and Bau anymore.

 

Yeah, all of those game winning homers and clutch hits were really turning my stomach as well.

Posted
Morales is full time DH

 

Can Pearce fill a whole season playing OF?

 

That's the only way to make sure he gets full playing time if we get Edwin back too

 

Is Pearce as bad in the OF as Bautista for example?

 

 

We're not getting Edwin back now and Pearce is not a bad defender at all.

Posted
Morales is full time DH

 

Can Pearce fill a whole season playing OF?

 

That's the only way to make sure he gets full playing time if we get Edwin back too

 

Is Pearce as bad in the OF as Bautista for example?

 

I think the writing is on the wall now as far as Edwin is concerned.

Posted

Pearce has been quite a lot worse in the second halves in his career. Maybe that's partly due to all the injuries, maybe he just can't physically handle playing every day for whatever reason.

 

Regardless, this is an excellent signing at the price. Our bench right now has Pearce (1.5 WAR projection, could be higher), Upton (difficult to project, but likely 1 tp 1.5 WAR if used correctly and he hits more like he did in SD), and Barney (likely 1 to 1.5 WAR). Those are very valuable part time contributions for where we are on the curve.

 

Now if we could upgrade Upton to Dyson (we should have no problem trading Upton given he's basically free), we'd really be on to something with the bench.

 

Given the extra bat that kills lefties, I wonder if this is a prelude to possibly going after Moss? He's slightly above average defensively in the outfield, hits righties well, and probably comes at a reasonable price.

Posted
Morales is full time DH

 

Can Pearce fill a whole season playing OF?

 

That's the only way to make sure he gets full playing time if we get Edwin back too

 

Is Pearce as bad in the OF as Bautista for example?

 

I think it's really unlikely we get Edwin back at this point. With the Upton/Carrera/Smoak pieces in play (where Smoak presumably gets actual playing time), I think if we can get Fowler, we're pretty much done on the offensive side, save for identifying who backs up Martin.

Community Moderator
Posted
This doesn't necessarily close the door on Edwin, he can still split 1B/DH with Morales, with Pearce playong primarily OF.

 

Reports have come out saying the jays have closed the door on Edwin.

Posted
Possibly, but with destinations dwindling and the pick attached, I would guess that's unlikely at this point.

 

What do you think he gets then?

 

I know it's hard to put oneself in Edwin's shoes, but turning down $80 million to play in a city that you love; where you have tremendous fan support; and where the team has been knocking on the door the last couple of seasons; it just seems like a regrettable misstep.

 

Idk I think rejecting a decent but at the time not spectacular offer that early in FA seems pretty reasonable to me. It's like BTS said, how serious were the Jays? Seems like they gave him a take it or leave it deal back when nobody was signing deals yet. That'd be tough for one of the top bats on the market to accept without at least mulling it over or seeing what other teams would be interested.

Posted
Reports have come out saying the jays have closed the door on Edwin.

 

I think that is speculation due to the Pearce Signing but i agree that if the door isn't closed it is only open a pubic hair.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Blue Jays community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...