Toronto Blue Jays 2026 Hitter of the Year

The Blue Jays scored 648 runs in 2026. That was the lowest number in the majors this year, and the worst in franchise history (in a full season) since 1980. Of the 25 players who stepped to the plate for Toronto, only seven were above average offensively, according to FanGraphs. Only four reached double-digit home runs. 

The defense was much better, thanks largely to a phenomenal group of catchers. Still, the Jays' position players finished the season with a mediocre 19.1 fWAR, a huge step back from last year's 32.6. The pitching staff overcame countless injuries to produce postseason-calibre numbers, but the bats couldn't back them up. 

Of course, the blame doesn't fall on everyone. A handful of Blue Jays hitters still had seasons worth celebrating, and those are the names you'll find below.

Read More 

• Toronto Blue Jays 2026 Starter of the Year
• Toronto Blue Jays 2026 Reliever of the Year

Honourable Mentions

I came into this exercise planning to pick a top three and a couple of honourable mentions. After thinking back on the season and looking at the numbers, I decided there were only two players who deserved serious consideration to be Jays Centre's Hitter of the Year. All three players I was considering for the bronze medal position on this list felt more like honourable mentions, so that's how I left them. They're listed here in alphabetical order.

Brett Bateman

• 2026 Stats: 41 G, 181 PA, 2 HR, 3 SB, .329/.402/.424, 138 wRC+, +4 FRV, 1.9 fWAR

Brett Bateman was a stud for the Blue Jays post-deadline. He hit .329 with 28 runs scored and a 138 wRC+, flashing every tool except for power. His 1.9 fWAR didn't just lead Toronto from the day of his call-up onward – it placed him among the top 20 position players in the league. 

As terrific as Bateman was, the fact that a rookie who only played a quarter of a season was even in consideration for this list says as much about the Jays' disappointing year as it does about Bateman himself. The kid deserves plenty of praise, but I can't justify anything more than an honorable mention for a player who didn't debut until August 7.

Andrés Giménez

• 2026 Stats: 148 G, 508 PA, 9 HR, 20 SB, .244/.291/.359, 81 wRC+, +16 FRV 2.8 fWAR

We technically call this article "Hitter of the Year," but really, it's our award for position players. I needed to mention that here, because Andrés Giménez isn't on this list for what he did with the stick. Rather, he compensated for an 81 wRC+ (sixth-worst among qualified AL hitters) with good baserunning (20 SB) and superb defensive range (19 OAA).  

In his first full season at shortstop, Giménez ranked third at his position (and top 10 in MLB) with a +16 Fielding Run Value. That helped him finish with 2.8 fWAR, second-most on the Blue Jays. He might have earned that bronze medal I mentioned if it weren't for some other defensive metrics (like DRS and DRP) not being as high on his glovework at short. While FanGraphs will tell you he had about a three-win season, Baseball Reference and Baseball Prospectus put him closer to one-win territory. 

Nathan Lukes

• 2026 Stats: 125 G, 450 PA, 10 HR, 1 SB, .277/.327/.387, 102 wRC+, +8 FRV, 2.2 fWAR

Nathan Lukes had a solid season. I wish he could have played more of a supporting role, but it's not his fault that he was one of Toronto's better all-around players. 

Lukes posted a wRC+ just above league average, thanks to his strong splits against righties (and his limited playing time against lefties). He also played strong defense in right field. His range was good, and his arm was dangerous, helping him keep runners honest and mow them down when they dared to test him. Lukes was one of only seven players with 10 or more outfield assists in 2026, and he ranked third in Statcast's arm value metric. 

Runner-Up: Alejandro Kirk

• 2026 Stats: 79 G, 313 PA, 10 HR, 1 SB, .278/.351/.415, 114 wRC+, +10 FRV, 2.8 fWAR

If it weren't for the broken thumb that shelved him for two months, Alejandro Kirk might have earned the top spot. He essentially repeated his All-Star 2025 season, albeit in three-fifths of the games. Kirk's .767 OPS and 114 wRC+ were well above average for a catcher, while his glove was elite by every measure. 

Particularly impressive was Kirk's work in the second half. It seemed like his thumb injury was still bothering him in June and early July. After the All-Star break, however, he took off. His 138 wRC+ ranked third among qualified catchers in the second half, while his .851 OPS ranked fourth. Combine that with his strong defense, and he posted 2.5 fWAR post-deadline, second among catchers and 13th in all of MLB. 

Still just 27 years old, Kirk is one of the best catchers in baseball. The Blue Jays are very fortunate to have him under contract for less than $50 million over the next four years.

Hitter of the Year: Kazuma Okamoto

• 2026 Stats: 156 G, 636 PA, 33 HR, 1 SB, .232/.310/.452, 113 wRC+, -2 FRV, 3.0 fWAR

Kazuma Okamoto hit 33 home runs in 2026, more than twice as many as any of his teammates. He also led Toronto in runs, RBI, walks, and every version of position player WAR. The result of it all was the best season Blue Jays fans have seen from a rookie hitter since Eric Hinske.

It wasn't all perfect. Okamoto may have set the Blue Jays' rookie home run record, but he also set the franchise record for strikeouts in a season. He missed on nearly one-third of his swings. Yet, he made up for the strikeouts with timely hitting and power to all fields. Sure, he had his ups and downs, but by and large, Okamoto was the one hitter Blue Jays fans could count on throughout the season. 

And that's why he's Jays Centre's 2026 Toronto Blue Jays Hitter of the Year.

Do you approve of Blue Jays ownership?

Do you approve of Blue Jays ownership?

• Do you approve of Blue Jays ownership? Required
  

  
• Save

See All Blue Jays Polls >