I'm super against giving fat players longer term contracts, but everyone knows the tables you posted so lets go beyond that. What are the other options for LF? The fact that they should be a win now team, and that Melky isn't that heavy like you said means maybe they should sign him. Also, I'd like to see those tables broken down by games played, do heavier players just get hurt more after 30? Then you start the debate as to whether Melky could become injury prone.