Read this article and start to understand why our hitting is in the state it is. Mattingly didn't have a clue what he was doing let alone how to explain it to someone else. Granted he was 24 here, but it seems much of his philosophy is still on the wrong side of this conversation.
https://vault.si.com/vault/1986/04/14/a-real-rap-session
Some Highlights:
1. the whole start of the conversation about shifting weight. Very interesting read.
2. "BOGGS: If your name was Webster, not Williams, what would be your definition of a slump?
WILLIAMS: The inability to get hold of a ball and hit it with authority according to my potential."
"
3. Do you think you make more outs in the air or on the ground?
MATTINGLY: I think more in the air.
WILLIAMS: I tried to hit every ball I ever hit in the air, and I made more outs on the ground than in the air. Wade, I know you make more outs on the ground.
BOGGS: I popped up twice all season. But to me hitting the ball in the air means hitting a line drive, and I hit far more balls in the air.
WILLIAMS: Why do you think [Carlton] Fisk hit so many home runs last year? Because he hit the ball in the air more often.
MATTINGLY: I want to make more outs on the ground. I think I've got a better chance of getting a hit.
WILLIAMS: You know what they would say about Don Mattingly. We'll give him the hit. How many doubles did you have? Triples? Homers?
MATTINGLY: Forty-eight doubles, three triples, 35 homers.
WILLIAMS: They weren't on the ground. That's where your production was, so why hit the ball on the ground?"
4. "MATTINGLY: Dave Winfield will hit a home run, I'll ask him what the pitch was, and he'll shake his head and say, "I don't know.""