The difference between Judge and Vlad, is that the Yankees really wanted him and the whole Giants thing just drove up what they had to pay.
It is obvious Shapiro is not as high on Vlad as others on this board or in the media. I agree with Shapiro on this. I have been heavily critical of Shapiro and think he is too risk averse to do what you need to do to go to the next level in many cases.
However, I agree with Mark in this case.
Barker said it best. All it takes is one person in that room on the FO side to not have the confidence and it can kill a deal.
The FO saw a player who came to camp overweight in his early 20s when your metabolism is working full speed. They had him move off 3b to 1b for this.
Then he had inconsistent seasons relative to the money he is asking. He is a dumb ass on the base-paths and his defense is dubious at 1b. Apart from the metrics, former pro 1b players have criticized his footwork and positioning on the bag at 1b
He has not demonstrated great leadership by actions on or off the field that I can tell.
Vlad stated he was dealing with issues mentally during his down years. Ok, he is only human, but from a business perspective you probably need to consider his mental toughness.
Vlad really only performed at an elite level 3.5 out of the 6 months last year.
If we got Tucker vice Vlad, within 2 months the fan base would be Vlad who. Shapiro is also correct, winning takes care of all reference players the fan base “like” that leave the Team.
Keeping Vlad at an insane amount of money does nothing to help the Team take the next step. We have had Vlad and still have not won. I bet you could get more wins spreading that money around or going after a change of status quo impact player like Tucker as an example.
Verdict- Must trade by deadline or sooner!
When the Blue Jays got rid of fan favorites Fred McGriff and Tony Fernandez, partly to shake up the status quo, it was the best move the Blue Jays ever made.