You stated this is maybe the best off season ever. Regardless of how they were acquired and hindsight, just Martin and Donaldson make it better than this year IMO. I believed that at the time with no benefit of hindsight.
You are also using assumptions that this year has been a good year so far.
Cease- Excellent; however he averages 5ip.. How much is he really going to move the needle vs Bassitt and Scherzer etc.
Ponce (a guy who hung around all my Fantasy teams for years before went to Korea).
Kyle Hart won the equivalent of the Cy Young in Korea in 2024. He started out strong in MLB in 2025, but ended up being demoted to AAA and eventually DFAd.
Jury is out on Ponce
Okamoto is not an improvement over Bo who we lost, will be 30 in the summer and supposedly is not good at 3b... Jury is always out on the Japanese hitters. Not all are Ohtani, especially first 6 month/season.
I like the Rogers pick up for back end BP.
I think we still need a closer who can close the big game.
Our problem really wasn't SP last year.
We went 18 inning game 3 and couldn't get a hit. We couldn't score a run after the 6th inning in game 7.
We obviously couldn't score enough runs in game 2, 3, 6 and 7.
Again, off season is NOT over and lots of players and trades to be made.
However, we are a net negative on offense at the moment when I think that is our biggest need coming into the off-season.
Add to that there will be regression. I don't see Springer repeating 2025 for one.
One injury to Varsho or Kirk or they have down years, we aren't looking so hot.
Santander, who knows what we will get. Plus, he is not exactly contact put the ball in play, control the strike zone guy that led to our offensive success last year.
Let's see what their finished product is.......