Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm not sure I trust his arm holding up long term so not a big deal when we miss out on the top free agent for the fourth straight year.

Old-Timey Member
Posted

Ya like others are saying... im good with finishing 2nd here if it means he wants something like a 350/10 deal.  There are plenty of other elite SPs who can be had for a third of that cost/risk. 

Posted
15 minutes ago, Jays24 said:

Ya like others are saying... im good with finishing 2nd here if it means he wants something like a 350/10 deal.  There are plenty of other elite SPs who can be had for a third of that cost/risk. 

Skubal is the only elite rotation option in free agency this offseason. 

Old-Timey Member
Posted

He's going to want a historic contract for a SP. A 9-10 year deal for a 30 year old SP who just had some elbow issues a few months ago is very risky. Much like with Tucker, I don't mind losing out on this one either. 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
6 minutes ago, max silver said:

Skubal is the only elite rotation option in free agency this offseason. 

Sure, hes on his own level but there are plenty of other SPs that are great options with a lot less risk/money.  Id rather see those funds used to address our hitting.  

Community Moderator
Posted

Skubal carries obvious risk, being a pitcher set to receive close to 400M. But if you look at recent top tier aces - guys like Verlander, Scherzer, Greinke, Cole, DeGrom, even Wheeler - I think an 8-10 year mega-deal starting at their age-30 season would have worked out just fine. Kershaw maybe less so, but it wouldn't have been catastrophic. You just want to avoid a Strasburg situation. I'd be pretty excited if the team signed him. 

Posted

The Jays were always going to chase after Skubal, we all knew it. I hope they land him, it's not my money after all.

But in the most likely event they miss, I'd be happy with something like 1 x $22 for Gausman and 1 x $10 for Bieber on a pillow deal.

I have zero issue running it back with last year's rotation + Soriano, especially when it's very likely the Jays get a lot more than 3.2 IP from Ponce, and Berrios will be back at some point as well.

Posted
38 minutes ago, Jays24 said:

Ya like others are saying... im good with finishing 2nd here if it means he wants something like a 350/10 deal.  There are plenty of other elite SPs who can be had for a third of that cost/risk. 

If Soriano is a #4, then I'd like a list of the other "elite" options available this offseason...

Old-Timey Member
Posted

I could be way off, but I feel like Peralta is exactly the type of SP the Jays would target. They pay big for durability, and there's no QO attached. I'm sure they'd rather have Skubal (obviously) but risk, contract size, AAV, injury history, etc, has to be packaged into the equation. 

Posted
5 hours ago, Governator said:

41fo8MxduzL._SY445_SX342_ML2_.jpg

The only way Atkins can convince him to sign with the Jays will be if he overpaid  more than the Dodgers, NYK, Mets, Boston, Atlanta, Cubs, so less than 0.1% this can happen. So Jays need find someone else, and the options in free agency can be Peralta, Rogers or Soroka. Peralta will be a mistake, coz in my opinion, sopmeone that Brewers and Rays no interested to keep is a red flag, I have some David Price vibe in this case. Rogers technically should be the safe choice, but he lost velocity last year, so this can be a concern. Soroka no bad, but do we need another fourth starter? We already have Soriano and Yesevage for such role, and what we lack, is a top 2 starter. Joe Ryan can also be an option if Twins realize that with their actual lineup they have 0% chance to participate in the WS. But do Ryan worth to give prospects like King , Parker in return? I don't think so. To be Atkins, I will sign Rogers to similar contract he give to Gausman in  the past, and I will add more Japanese players to the lineup. Suzuki to play LF, Sato to be DH, coz we all know Santander will end up injured during spring training camp, and finaly Taira for the bullpen and to start game time to time in a similar role of Sasoki with the Dodgers. To finish , sign Chisholm to add more speed and Vesia to keep Little out of the team.

Posted

Seriously, to have Okamoto, Suzuki, Sato and Taira in Jays uniform, will be very good for business in Japan. No as good than Dodgers with Ohtani, but no far, coz all these Japanese players are all star in Japan. For John Schneider this mean 75+HR, 220+ RBI, and a bullpen arm who can throw 100 MHP fastball and who can start few inning when he use a committee of reliever who start game, or maybe he can close game when Varland rest.

Posted
4 hours ago, glory said:

I could be way off, but I feel like Peralta is exactly the type of SP the Jays would target. They pay big for durability, and there's no QO attached. I'm sure they'd rather have Skubal (obviously) but risk, contract size, AAV, injury history, etc, has to be packaged into the equation. 

Yeah Peralta feels like the type of arm Atkins and company like. They love durability. Similar to Berrios, Gausman, Bassitt, Soriano etc. 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
2 hours ago, jaysblue said:

If the Blue Jays sign Skubal, I'm getting a Skubal jersey for Christmas! 

I said id prefer others at the pricepoint he'll probably get but ill be right behind you on that.  Hopefully Skubal counts as the "special budget" and we still go get 2 big bats.  That'll allow me to cope with our current toronto sports teams lol

Posted

Luckily, we only gotta wait less than 2 weeks.  Probably the only good thing about this lockout is that Free agency wont drag out lol. 

Posted

Wow. To be honest Jays kind-of dodged a bullet 2 out of the 3.   And last 7 years of Ohtani contract might be awful if his knee is messed up. 

Could you imagine how awful last year would have been with Tucker?  I think he actually would have lost the Jays a win or two if say Lukes had been replaced by Tucker. 

Like last year except payroll 35 million more and wins 2 less, and 2 historic under-performances by 35 million dollar men instead of just one. 

Posted

2/3 I think I mean Ohtani, Sasaki and Tucker.    Sasaki may be OK long term, but I think he would have been worse in 2025 then any of the Jays pitchers whos innings he would have taken, and not added much in 2026 either. 

Posted

Ohtani, Sasaki and Tucker.  Those were the three you kept refreshing the X and this message forum and at one point (Ohtani on a plane, Jays get Straw to clear room) you thought it was 100%. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Blue Jays community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...