Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account
  • Blue Jays News & Analysis

    If the Blue Jays Add a Starter, He Better Stay Healthy

    The Blue Jays appear to be active in the starting pitcher market, but is there a specific trait they should be targeting?

    Owen Hill
    Image courtesy of Gregory Fisher, Jeff Hanisch, & Nathan Ray Seebeck - Imagn Images via Reuters Connect

    Blue Jays Video

    The Toronto Blue Jays have to address their league-worst offense heading into next season. Many expected it to be their number one priority. So it was a bit of a surprise when one of the winter’s first reports from Ben Nicholson-Smith was that the Jays were going to be motivated in the starting pitching market. 

    Think about it, though. What does this front office and coaching staff do better than identify, acquire and get the most out of starting pitchers?

    Since the 2019-’20 offseason, from the free agent market alone, they've brought in arms like Hyun Jin Ryu, Steven Matz, Kevin Gausman, Chris Bassitt, Yusei Kikuchi, Max Scherzer, Dylan Cease, and Cody Ponce, without mentioning trades for guys like Robbie Ray, José Berríos, and, more recently, José Soriano.

    The formula has been to use their financial muscle to bring starters in or keep them around, and it’s allowed them to maintain a strong rotation year-over-year, despite the only notable homegrown starters to contribute to the rotation being Alek Manoah and Trey Yesavage.

    Traditionally, we’d say the way the Jays have built their rotation isn’t as sustainable as drafting, developing and graduating their own starting pitchers, but they’ve kind of proved that notion wrong, even if it’s taken some hefty checks to get the job done. 

    It makes all the sense in the world that they’re looking at leaning into an area where they’ve had a lot of recent success, but the process isn’t as simple as inserting the second- or third-best starting pitcher on the free agent market into the rotation.

    As always, all of the available free agents have different skill sets, strengths, weaknesses, and, as with any pitcher, a certain level of risk.

    If the Jays are going to stay hot in the starting pitcher market, I think step one should be targeting availability and durability. They should be asking who’s the most likely to take the ball every fifth day.

    One of the reasons we were selling ourselves on the ‘26 Jays as a dark-horse team to go on a run if they snuck into the playoffs was the top-end talent in the rotation. Cease, Soriano, and Yesavage will continue to be a dangerous 1-2-3 in ‘27, and while adding a fourth top-end guy to the mix would be a ton of fun, the Jays probably feel pretty comfortable with those three guys leading the way.

    The issue that plagued the Jays most in ‘26 wasn’t so much the performance of their starters, and more that they simply didn’t get enough innings from them. Their 749.1 IP from starters was the third-lowest mark in baseball. I simply don’t think many teams in MLB could have survived the absurd number of starting pitcher injuries the Jays faced. 

    There is a certain level of randomness to injuries, and pitchers getting hurt is the unfortunate reality of professional baseball in 2027, but finding a way to mitigate the risk of injuries completely derailing the rotation again is necessary to insulate the top-end talent that already exists at the top of the rotation.

    Sonny Gray is said to be partial to choosing a team close to his home of Tennessee, but his track record of health is exactly what I have in mind when talking about durability.

    Since the start of his thirties, Gray has battled a number of different lower body and back issues, but none of them have been particularly serious. Excluding the 2020 COVID season, he’s started at least 22 games every season since his rookie year. The thing about Gray that I like the most is that he’s never had a major arm injury in his 14-year major league career. 

    Concerned about adding a guy heading into his age 37 season? Gray had an 88th percentile run value on fastballs for the Red Sox in ‘26 despite bringing well below average velocity to the table, an indication he should continue to perform as he gets deeper into his thirties. He’s probably not going to put up a sub-three ERA again in ‘27, but it’s an easy bet that he’ll be able to give a team between 25 and 30 starts.

    Kevin Gausman has seen a ton of success with his fastball/splitter combination, a combo that likely won’t age as well as Gray’s, but Jays fans know how durable he is, having made more than 30 starts in every season since 2021. 

    Neither of these are guys I want starting game one or two of a playoff series, in ‘27 or beyond, but the Jays already have those guys in place anyways.

    One more name I’d propose that might be a bit more exciting is Freddy Peralta. His injury history isn’t quite as clean, with a few shoulder injuries between 2019 and '22, but he’s put together four healthy seasons in a row heading into his free agency. 

    The injury history brings more risk than Gray or Gausman, and it’ll almost certainly take a longer commitment and higher AAV, but he offers a pretty exciting mix of upside with durability.

    Ultimately, adding upside wherever one can find it is always a positive thing, even if it comes with risk, but the Jays need to be healthy enough in the rotation to get into the playoffs. Failing at this was a big part of the disappointing 2026 season.

    There will always be some level of unpredictability when it comes to pitcher health. There’s no pitcher in baseball that we can guarantee will make 30 starts. But the Jays have had success making these bets in the past, and if they’re going to take a shot on another free agent starter, I expect them to bet on availability.


    Want to play the role of Blue Jays general manager? Check out our free-to-use "You're The GM" offseason tool and build your own Blue Jays roster!

    Build Your 2027 Roster

    Follow Jays Centre For Toronto Blue Jays News & Analysis

    Think you could write an article like this one? We're looking for additional contributors, and we pay for all our content! Please click here, fill out the form, and someone will reply with more information.

    Recent Blue Jays Articles

    Recent Blue Jays Videos


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    There are no comments to display.



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...