Atkins has done a lot of good, and I feel fine about him going forward as GM, but it's really disappointing to see the lack of homegrown pitching in his 7-year tenure, especially considering the org he was coming from has had fantastic pitching development. It's unfair to have the GM shoulder the blame alone. There's a lot that goes into pitching development including having good drafts, the right player development methodologies, good training staff, analytics, technological infrastructure, and some level of good luck. It takes a village for sure, but our record with developing pitchers is so dismal when you zoom in:
Failure(s)/didn't pan out:
- TJ Zeuch
- Ryan Borucki
- Anthony Kay
- Thomas Hatch
- Bowden Francis
- Patrick Murphy
- Jacob Waguespack
- Sean Reid-Foley
- Trent Thornton
- Hector Perez
- David Paulino
TBD/still some hope:
- Nate Pearson
- Julian Merryweather
Success stories:
- Tim Mayza
- Jordan Romano
- Alek Manoah
Maybe if you play the percentages and compare it to other orgs, we are comparable. But to have 3 real homegrown success stories on the pitching side the last 7 years seems like a really bad track record. There is very clearly a proven process with developing pitchers that works as evidenced by the Rays, Astros, Dodgers, Yankees, Guardians who churn out key members of rotations/bullpens every year. Our process in identifying and developing pitchers seems to be broken somewhere.