FFS...the Jays literally could have signed Ohtani and the offense would still been awful (especially since Turner wouldn't have been on the team). The offense is s*** because Bo, Vlad, Kirk and Springer are all terrible. Raise your hand if you knew Bo was going to turn into Ryan Goins with a 62 wRC+ this year...
IMO, the FO banked on Vlad and Kirk improving in a predictable manner for hitters with their pedigree and age - and, well - here we are getting the 5th percentile result. IMO, it was a very difficult position to be in. You either sold Vlad and Kirk at 50 cents on the dollar or you trust they improve in accordance with statistical data. I mean we could have sold Varsho for 50 cents on the dollar this offseason too....but I'm happy we didn't.
I'm sad to see Springer fall off this cliff. When we signed him, he seemed like a good candidate to age gracefully....moving from CF to RF, with some old man hitting skills that should keep him relevant past 35 or 36. Sometimes you get Justin Turner or Nelly Cruz and other times you're just done. The Cards probably feel the same with Goldy, Astros with Abreu. It sucks.
You can blame the hitting coaches all you want if it makes you feel good. I strongly believe those coaches have a MUCH smaller impact on the player results than you think. Do you guys think after the Leafs exit the 1st round again, they should fire their skating coaches and shooting coaches? Me neither.
Atkins and Schneider won't survive this season, but I'm not so sure there was some other GM wizard out there who would have done drastically better, given these circumstances. Imagine if Atkins signed Ohtani and was run out of town the same year. It almost happened!