Hurl made a good point about the 4 innings two days ago though. I'd still prefer him over rushing Stroman but I could see the argument for taking him out of consideration in this particular case.
Hendriks is the obvious choice here. As good as anyone in the 'pen and can go as long as needed. Also, since the Jays don't have the lead, this is a situation where Gibbons allows himself to use him.
Alomar is a HOF for his career but his contribution to the Jays is a bit overstated. What Bautista has contributed over 8 seasons easily trumps what Alomar contributed in 5. It's not even close.