We landed the best starter of the entire deadline which counts for something.
If you compare the individual deals I think we held our own too:
Jays gave up #5.5 and #11 for 5.5 years of Varland.
Phillies gave up #3 and #9 for 2.5 years of Duran.
Mets gave up #5 and #13 for half a year of Tyler Rogers.
Some say 5.5 years of control doesn’t matter for relievers and I think that has some merit, but Varland is making the minimum for 2.5 more years and Duran will be getting paid pretty well via arb.
The Yankees pulled their usual heist. They traded nine prospects (ranked from #10–#91) for Bednar (1.5 years), Doval (2.5), and Bird (3.5). But those guys are in arb, Bednar/Doval were demoted this year, and Doval reportedly has makeup issues.
We gave up #35 for half a year of Dominguez. The Yanks may regret going quantity over quality. Sometimes those lesser ranked guys can pop. Tatis Jr. was a throw in for James Shields 9 years ago.