Smoak: 305 PA, 32 XBH, 53 RBI, 28 BB, 83K
Colabello: 336 PA, 32 XBH, 53 RBI, 22 BB, 88K
If you take away the fact that Colabello has had a bunch more ground balls find holes for singles, the production between the two is essentially the same. Go with the guy with better defense.