Max gave up 3 and struck out 11 at the end of July in a game where he was touching 97 and hitting 95 and 96 regularly. His next 4 starts he gave up 1 run, 2 runs, 1 run and 1 run. His stuff looked great. Then the end of August and into September we saw a run of poor outings. The velocity dipped. The breaking balls weren't as sharp. The command wasn't as good. He's an old guy. Was it just physically he wasn't feeling as good?
I still see Max as a bit of a wild card. He's had time off. They saw the 5 inning simulated game. If they liked what they saw and his stuff is playing up again, I could see the veteran with the adrenaline of the playoffs, the focus that a veteran has, providing a good start in the playoffs. If he starts a game and he comes out hitting 96 vs 93 his spin rates on the off speed pitches are likely higher too. Time will tell, but I won't be surprised if he's on the roster next series.