the big thing for me is the back...probably just because my wife has a bad back and problem with buldging disks. She's had an mri and is on meds for her back and no she isn't a fatty...she's in great shape, but I understand the issues people with back problems go through and to be a catcher with a bad back and all the other injuries..it's a red flag to say the least.
The anti AA crowd say D'arnaud and Syndergaard and the hear all star and cy young....but D'arnaud has some serious risks with his health and syder is just now pitching at AA...these were definitely taken into account when the trade was made. RA had 3 solid seasons..not one. This year he's had his own health issues and pitched through them...some believe they are not to blame for his performance...those who say that may or may not be right.
RA has pitched some great games..the last two were quality starts...in three more starts the RA bandwagon will be making a stop and people will either be jumping on or jumping off....we'll see...I predict good things because I can rationalize poor performance do to the neck and back spasms he had and because I'm just a positive person to begin with..lol