Arencibia is naturally gifted. He even had Joe Torre gushing over him this Spring. A lean, muscular athlete with a strong arm and a power bat at the catcher position? Sounds too good to be true. It is.
He just doesn't get it and simply doesn't improve. The stone hands, the bad footwork, the bad pitch selection, the refusal to square up behind the plate, the never positioning his mitt over his right knee with left handed batters at the plate, all of it just ruin what baseball people see in him. There's no denying that the kid has a ceiling far beyond what we've seen but without the work and an open mind, there's no way he reaches it.