Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
8 minutes ago, Brownie19 said:

If Skubal was offered $400M - why hasn't he signed yet?  Is it because the Mets org sucks so much?  It's insane.  We're not offering $400M+

He probably thinks he can milk a team for $50m more 

Which may be fair, we live in a world where 9 HR first basemen with broken swings can milk teams for half a billion 

Posted

The Mets are a s*** show and everyone knows it, while the Jays have a reputation of treating players exceptionally well. I'm not convinced the Dodgers are out of this, they'll probably find a way to bring him back when it's all said and done, but if it's between the Mets and the Jays, then the Jays probably have a real shot. The Mets reputation has taken a massive hit with their clubhouse issues, handling of franchise cornerstones (Alonso), etc. Boras guys love money though (or at least Boras pushes them to take the money) so we will see. 

Posted
16 hours ago, Bob_Gratton said:

Atkins should tell Boras that he match Mets offers, but he should be active right now and add great offensive players, improve the bullpen, so Skubal will see that the Jays are serious about to win. When Atkins wait too long and all 2nd and thrd best options are gone, this make me think he just say bulshit, he don't really intend spend too much, and instead sign cheaper options. This time he need to sign guys that will instantly improve the offense by far, and to avoid to be the Christmas turkey again, start to discuss with Peralta, Rogers and King right now, to see if they are seriously interested to sign here, like he did with Cease and Gausman in past, and no wait to 1rst december for Skubal decision to sign with Mets or Dodgers.

I’m sure the Jays are doing their due diligence on other free agents, but I do agree this front office tends to wait for a decision from its biggest target before really moving on with the rest of the offseason.

We saw it with Ohtani and Soto, where it felt like they were waiting for those decisions before pivoting elsewhere. Last offseason was different because they landed Cease early, which allowed the rest of the offseason to fall into place. 

It just seems to be how this front office prefers to operate. I give them credit for consistently taking swings at the biggest names, but the downside sometimes is that if they miss, you risk being left scrambling while other good players might have already signed elsewhere.

 

Posted
1 hour ago, jaysblue said:

I’m sure the Jays are doing their due diligence on other free agents, but I do agree this front office tends to wait for a decision from its biggest target before really moving on with the rest of the offseason.

We saw it with Ohtani and Soto, where it felt like they were waiting for those decisions before pivoting elsewhere. Last offseason was different because they landed Cease early, which allowed the rest of the offseason to fall into place. 

It just seems to be how this front office prefers to operate. I give them credit for consistently taking swings at the biggest names, but the downside sometimes is that if they miss, you risk being left scrambling while other good players might have already signed elsewhere.

 

I think that Ohtani and Soto both largely drove free agency to a bit of a halt as the entire league was in a bit of a holding pattern until they made their decisions. With Ohtani in particular I don't think anyone of note signed until he came off of the board, and if I recall correctly it was a very similar situation with Soto as well.

Posted
12 minutes ago, Eat My Shatkins said:

He leads all MLB pitchers in fWAR since 2022.

He'll be overpaid, but I don't think he's over rated.

He's possibly the best pitcher in MLB.

Here is what I mean:

30, coming off an injury, overrated mainly due to misleading small sample size comps to a handful of aberration Aces who were amazing forever (Scherzer, Verlander). Was never actually a "real horse".

Kershaw never had a 4 fWAR season after 30. 

$400M for an arm is NUTS

 

Posted
7 minutes ago, Laika said:

Here is what I mean:

30, coming off an injury, overrated mainly due to misleading small sample size comps to a handful of aberration Aces who were amazing forever (Scherzer, Verlander). Was never actually a "real horse".

Kershaw never had a 4 fWAR season after 30. 

$400M for an arm is NUTS

 

I think Gerrit Cole might be a decent comparable for Skubal as they are both power arms. Cole's deal hasn't provided any surplus value but he's provided solid production for the Yankees despite missing time due to the Tommy John surgery. My concern with Skubal is the litany of elbow and forearm issues as he's undergone three separate surgical repairs already and feels like a bit of a ticking time bomb. If the rumors of the $400 million offer from the Mets is true I'm close to the point where I'd rather see the club pursue different options as the thought of having both of Vlad and Skubal signed in their late 30's is semi terrifying. 

Posted
13 minutes ago, Laika said:

Here is what I mean:

30, coming off an injury, overrated mainly due to misleading small sample size comps to a handful of aberration Aces who were amazing forever (Scherzer, Verlander). Was never actually a "real horse".

Kershaw never had a 4 fWAR season after 30. 

$400M for an arm is NUTS

 

Yeah, agreed, but I’d also say true “workhorses” barely exist in today’s game anymore.

Would you say Skubal is also a product of that newer philosophy? He’s never really been used as a traditional workhorse in the Verlander/Scherzer sense, where you’re expecting 200+ innings and 30–33 starts every year. Teams just don’t employ starters the same way they did when Verlander and Scherzer were in their primes, when you could expect 200+ innings and 30–33 starts every year. I miss those days and that's what makes me even appreciate guys like Verlander and Scherzer even more. 

Nowadays, if an elite starter gives you 28–30 starts and 170–190 quality innings, that’s basically the modern-day version of a workhorse.

Posted

I understand Laika’s concern though.

Even look at David Price after he signed his mega-deal at 30. And I was actually surprised to see that Kershaw never posted another 4-WAR season after age 30 either.

I think you’re probably fine with Skubal for the next 2–3 years. The concern is the back half of a 6–7 year deal, when he’s into his mid-30s and the injury/decline risk naturally increases.

That said, the Jays have had a pretty good track record of keeping arms healthy and durable, so that at least makes me a little more comfortable taking the risk on an elite starter like Skubal.

Posted
3 hours ago, Eat My Shatkins said:

He leads all MLB pitchers in fWAR since 2022.

He'll be overpaid, but I don't think he's over rated.

He's possibly the best pitcher in MLB.

Overpaid? This depend, coz Gausman+Bieber+Scherzer or Skubal? Trevor Rogers+Michael King or Skubal? Peralta+Taira or Skubal?

 

 

 

Posted
2 hours ago, jaysblue said:

I understand Laika’s concern though.

Even look at David Price after he signed his mega-deal at 30. And I was actually surprised to see that Kershaw never posted another 4-WAR season after age 30 either.

I think you’re probably fine with Skubal for the next 2–3 years. The concern is the back half of a 6–7 year deal, when he’s into his mid-30s and the injury/decline risk naturally increases.

That said, the Jays have had a pretty good track record of keeping arms healthy and durable, so that at least makes me a little more comfortable taking the risk on an elite starter like Skubal.

Some pitchers remain good even if they are in mid 30s. Clemens, Scherzer, deGrom, Maddux, Smoltz, Glavine, Verlander, Colon are good examples.

Posted
11 minutes ago, Bob_Gratton said:

Some pitchers remain good even if they are in mid 30s. Clemens, Scherzer, deGrom, Maddux, Smoltz, Glavine, Verlander, Colon are good examples.

Yes, it turns out some of the legends of the game remained good in their 30's.  You forgot Randy Johnson!

Posted
14 minutes ago, Brownie19 said:

Yes, it turns out some of the legends of the game remained good in their 30's.  You forgot Randy Johnson!

Yes Johnson, Schilling, Valenzuela

Posted

Chris Sale after 2018 and at age-30 looked in trouble. Missed a lot of time due to injuries and wasn't his elite self until 2024 at age-35 in his first season with the Braves. 

Posted

I would 100% be happy if the Jays rolled the dice on a massive contract with Skubal.

It's not my money. Yeah, it might not work out, but if it does we would have a rotation anchored by two legit aces for the next several years. Both Cease and Skubal are top 5 in SP fWAR since 2022, and at 30/31 could easily have many good seasons left in them.

Community Moderator
Posted

The Jays are already in for a tough time with Vlad's contract. They can absorb that on a high payroll. But can they absorb that plus the back half of a Skubal contract? What if there is a salary cap and $85M is going towards two players, one of them being a fatter, right handed version of James Loney and the other being an old pitcher. 

I mean they would really be hitching their wagon to Vlad and Skubal for a solid decade. Egads. It's no longer one mega contract - it's the immovable foundation of your next "window". I mean you hope it's a window because you can't really rebuild if it's a wall.

It could work out! Just have to hope they can age well. Scherzer and Freeman. Votto and Kershaw or Cole (at the worst).

Posted

I'm not too worried about the introduction of a salary cap. If they do that there will most likely be a salary roll back (IIRC it was 24% roll backs when the NHL introduced a salary cap) and I imagine they will also have some sort of compliance buy outs available to teams.

Posted
7 hours ago, jaysblue said:

I’m sure the Jays are doing their due diligence on other free agents, but I do agree this front office tends to wait for a decision from its biggest target before really moving on with the rest of the offseason.

We saw it with Ohtani and Soto, where it felt like they were waiting for those decisions before pivoting elsewhere. Last offseason was different because they landed Cease early, which allowed the rest of the offseason to fall into place. 

It just seems to be how this front office prefers to operate. I give them credit for consistently taking swings at the biggest names, but the downside sometimes is that if they miss, you risk being left scrambling while other good players might have already signed elsewhere.

 

The offseason ends in 9 days bro, just elite/big names will go then the action restarts after they're ordered back to play. They'll be plenty of moves though prior to the 1st, no doubt.

Posted
6 hours ago, Laika said:

Here is what I mean:

30, coming off an injury, overrated mainly due to misleading small sample size comps to a handful of aberration Aces who were amazing forever (Scherzer, Verlander). Was never actually a "real horse".

Kershaw never had a 4 fWAR season after 30. 

$400M for an arm is NUTS

 

I agree, hard pass, although I won't hate hit. Injury risk at that number is assinine.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
8 minutes ago, Spanky__99 said:

I agree, hard pass, although I won't hate hit. Injury risk at that number is assinine.

What, you guys don't want to pay him a million dollars+ per game he appears in?  Cause that is what it is going to cost.

Hard pass indeed!

Old-Timey Member
Posted

Skubal would be one of those “excited if we sign him, relieved if he goes elsewhere” moves for me. That contract is going to age very badly (9+ years),  but the initial dopamine hit will be great (followed by the depression of knowing one of the best remaining seasons he will have left in his career may not happen or will be incredibly shortened due to the lockout).

Posted
3 minutes ago, glory said:

Skubal would be one of those “excited if we sign him, relieved if he goes elsewhere” moves for me. That contract is going to age very badly (9+ years),  but the initial dopamine hit will be great (followed by the depression of knowing one of the best remaining seasons he will have left in his career may not happen or will be incredibly shortened due to the lockout).

That is well said.  Describes exactly how I feel.

Posted

I couldn't care if the Jays signed Skubal or not. It's not my money. If they sign him, great! The potential to have one of the best 1-2 punches in baseball in Skubal and Cease is definitely exciting. 

If they don't sign him, I'm also okay with that. Plenty of other arms they could sign like bringing back Gausman or signing some other arms on 1-2 year deals. 

Posted

There will be an MLB Opening Day in 2027. 

If they f***ed that up in anyway with the game growing as it is and at its height of popularity, would be so stupid!

 

Posted
32 minutes ago, jaysblue said:

There will be an MLB Opening Day in 2027. 

If they f***ed that up in anyway with the game growing as it is and at its height of popularity, would be so stupid!

 

Union: Cap and floor is a non-starter

Owners: We won't compromise on a cap and floor.

There was never this level of rhetoric last time around. I'll be pleasantly surprised if no games are missed but i'm mentally preparing myself for a half season at best

Posted
35 minutes ago, L54 said:

They’re going to pay Fastball Freddy like three hours after Skubal signs in LA 

Based on the adjustments TB was able to make for Freddy in his short time there, that might be the best outcome.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Blue Jays community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...