hanton Old-Timey Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 something doesn't feel right about this signing but I hope I'm totally wrong and it works out
Laika Community Moderator Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 Look at his bWAR if you are confused by the price here Orgfiller and Spanky__99 2
Orgfiller Old-Timey Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 30 minutes ago, Brownie19 said: I hope this works out. I do like having different angles and stuff, but I have a hard time giving 3 years $39M to a guy who's 35 and throws 82 MPH. Suarez for $6M more seems like better value/upside. The numbers speak for themselves honestly. It’s unorthodox in every way, but Rogers gets the job done as well as anyone else. By RA9-WAR he’s arguably the best non Diaz option available in FA. max silver, Spanky__99, BatFlip and 1 other 3 1
Angrioter Old-Timey Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 Tyler is our best bullpen arm right now
Jonn Old-Timey Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 11 minutes ago, Spanky__99 said: They acquired another sidearm guy earlier today in Lee, was a good depth move. Yea I like that move as well 2 options and plenty of control. Will probably be up and down all year Spanky__99 1
Sasky05 Verified Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 34 minutes ago, Brownie19 said: I hope this works out. I do like having different angles and stuff, but I have a hard time giving 3 years $39M to a guy who's 35 and throws 82 MPH. Suarez for $6M more seems like better value/upside. I get your rationale, but maybe Saurez preferred to go to Atlanta. Sometimes we don't get our man.
Laika Community Moderator Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 Orgfiller, Terminator, JaysAllMighty and 3 others 4 2
Jonn Old-Timey Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 7 minutes ago, hanton said: something doesn't feel right about this signing but I hope I'm totally wrong and it works out It’s expensive but this is what happens when the top options go and the market scrambles to pick up the best remaining options. He is very very good though just isn’t as sexy because he doesn’t throw 98 Stangstag 1
Jonn Old-Timey Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 3 minutes ago, Laika said: That is quite the list to be apart of.
max silver Old-Timey Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 51 minutes ago, Bob_Gratton said: Seriously, Rogers 37m or Suarez 45m? Atkins probably tried to sign Suarez at discount, this didn't worked, and in panic he overpaid for Rogers. We f***ing still need a #1 closer, no Swanson replacement BatFlip, Jonn, Eat My Shatkins and 2 others 1 3 1
Terminator Old-Timey Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 52 minutes ago, Bob_Gratton said: Seriously, Rogers 37m or Suarez 45m? Atkins probably tried to sign Suarez at discount, this didn't worked, and in panic he overpaid for Rogers. We f***ing still need a #1 closer, no Swanson replacement Rogers is better but he’s discriminated against because he’s a submariner. Stangstag 1
Jonn Old-Timey Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 8 minutes ago, Terminator said: Rogers is better but he’s discriminated against because he’s a submariner. Jay’s cornering the market on them. Acquired 2 in one day! Although Lee is not quite from down under
Terminator Old-Timey Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 Ross Atkins has added 3 starting pitchers and 2 relievers before Cashman can even get out of his sleeping bag Eat My Shatkins, Omar, jaysblue and 5 others 2 6
Jonn Old-Timey Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 2 minutes ago, Terminator said: Ross Atkins has added 3 starting pitchers and 2 relievers before Cashman can even get out of his sleeping bag They still are considered the favourites for Imai. And if they bring back Bellinger I would say they had a good off-season. Hopefully they aren’t in on Tucker. Feels like it’s between us and the Dodgers again.
hanton Old-Timey Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 25 minutes ago, Laika said: break that down by leverage Spanky__99 1
glory Old-Timey Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 35 minutes ago, Laika said: Lmao wtf Okay uhhh Wtf dude How much? You can't do stuff like this and then NOT at least sign Bo Atkins probably has FU money to spend this winter if Rogers at $12M+ AAV was added before the big FAs came off the board. Atkins moves typically come out of no where (see Cease, Ponce, and now Rogers), so the fact that they are so specifically linked to Tucker makes me think they'll end up signing Bo. Stangstag and Spanky__99 2
The_DH Verified Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 I was hoping for a few more K's out of whoever we signed but I'm just imagining what it will look like when he comes in after Yesavage.
Spanky__99 Old-Timey Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 38 minutes ago, Orgfiller said: The numbers speak for themselves honestly. It’s unorthodox in every way, but Rogers gets the job done as well as anyone else. By RA9-WAR he’s arguably the best non Diaz option available in FA. Bam, love this... we want all the Roogy's, lol. Love the RA9 comment.
Pendleton Old-Timey Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 27 minutes ago, Terminator said: Rogers is better but he’s discriminated against because he’s a submariner. Chad Bradford walked for 235k so that Tyler Rogers could run to 37M Stangstag, Orgfiller and Spanky__99 2 1
L54 Old-Timey Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 Interesting signing. Seems like a lot Stangstag 1
BTS Community Moderator Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 I'm guessing it's Bruihl DFA'd to make room? I've never seen a pitching staff this deep in Toronto. It's insane: Hoffman Varland Rogers Garcia (if healthy) Nance (no options) Lauer Berrios Are probably locks if healthy. Then you have Miles who was picked in the Rule V. Bruihl is out of options. Then in AAA you have: Fluharty, Little, Fisher, Tiedemann etc... Like, the AAA crew is better than some teams' MLB pen. They can flip an arm or two for actual prospects if they want, because they don't actually have room for all of the pitching. Spanky__99 and Orgfiller 1 1
G-Snarls Community Moderator Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 I'm kind of OK not getting an "elite closer" when we have all those intriguing options. I feel like a couple of those guys will establish themselves as perfectly "closer capable". Stangstag 1
Terminator Old-Timey Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 37 minutes ago, Jonn said: They still are considered the favourites for Imai. And if they bring back Bellinger I would say they had a good off-season. Hopefully they aren’t in on Tucker. Feels like it’s between us and the Dodgers again. Theres still time but that’s a lot of “ifs”
Joltin Joe Verified Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 I'm not familiar with NL players, but he has good numbers
GoBlue41 Verified Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 If they like him, I like him!! If it's their money and not my own, I like him! If this doesn't prevent the team from going after more studs, I like him!! Good pickup tonight. This was just a sparkler. Maybe the big fireworks will be this weekend!
Jonn Old-Timey Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 26 minutes ago, BTS said: I'm guessing it's Bruihl DFA'd to make room? I've never seen a pitching staff this deep in Toronto. It's insane: Hoffman Varland Rogers Garcia (if healthy) Nance (no options) Lauer Berrios Are probably locks if healthy. Then you have Miles who was picked in the Rule V. Bruihl is out of options. Then in AAA you have: Fluharty, Little, Fisher, Tiedemann etc... Like, the AAA crew is better than some teams' MLB pen. They can flip an arm or two for actual prospects if they want, because they don't actually have room for all of the pitching. Yea it’s exciting. It’s a really strong group of relievers. The best pitching depth that I can personally remember.
Perfect Game Verified Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 Spanky__99, Gen.Disarray, Omar and 2 others 1 4
glory Old-Timey Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 Rogers had 77 and 81 appearances the last two seasons. A durable relief arm with John Schneider as manager is a recipe for an insane amount of appearances. Spanky__99 and Orgfiller 2
Perfect Game Verified Member Posted December 13, 2025 Posted December 13, 2025 You gotta think Rogers (Ed) is already planning the Rogers jersey giveaway night. Stangstag 1
JoJo Parker Dunedin Blue Jays - A SS On Tuesday, Parker was just 1-for-5, but the one hit was his first professional home run. Explore JoJo Parker News >
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now