Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
Contreras looked like he had some good numbers last year, is only 24, and over a full season would have put up more WAR than Murphy. Is this a real big upgrade for them?

 

Murphy >> Contreras

 

Contreras had batted ball luck in 2021. More importantly, he is a negative defensively, whereas Murphy is excellent defensively.

  • Replies 9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Community Moderator
Posted

Okay the Braves also sent Royber Salinas to Oakland

 

Looks like a 70 FB 60 CB relief prospect, maybe two years away. Fangraphs says 40 FV.

 

That makes it a bit better for Oakland, they get another lottery ticket arm.

Posted
I think so

 

Ruiz has like, 6th percentile max EV. He's a slap hitter!

 

Am I reading this correctly that Ruiz stole 86 bases in 2022 between AA/AAA/MLB? f*** me! With 16 HRs and a K% <20%. I have to think most of the scouting reports on him are outdated as they seem to reference this guy with a K% in the high 20's. This still feels like a below average return for Oakland, but there has to be some upside in this Ruiz guy.

Posted

Vazquez is the last obstacle in the way of the Jays catcher trade, so hopefully he signs tonight and gets it over with.

 

Edit: Vazquez going to the Twins.

Posted
Vazquez is the last obstacle in the way of the Jays catcher trade, so hopefully he signs tonight and gets it over with.

 

Edit: Vazquez going to the Twins.

 

Isn't Mike Zunino still unsigned?

Posted
They have this weird thing where they NEED to get MLB ready players in the deal

 

Oh come on man don't be obtuse. The A's made out like bandits with Brett Lawrie and Kevin Smith as major league ready pieces in the Donaldson and Chapman trades.

Posted
So what’s the catcher market look like now and who needs one?

 

Based on earlier rumors, the Astros, Guardians, and Cubs are probably the most likely suitors. D-Backs probably won't make a deal for Jansen, and not sure if the Padres are a match trade-wise even though they have a clear need.

Posted

 

That's a real interesting trade. Those rumours of Oakland's ask on Murphy had to be ********, I think.

Posted
Murphy >> Contreras

 

Contreras had batted ball luck in 2021. More importantly, he is a negative defensively, whereas Murphy is excellent defensively.

 

Jim is correct.

Posted
Based on earlier rumors, the Astros, Guardians, and Cubs are probably the most likely suitors. D-Backs probably won't make a deal for Jansen, and not sure if the Padres are a match trade-wise even though they have a clear need.

 

Let’s play for fun…. With those 3 teams mentioned let’s take Jansen out of the equation and add Kirk.

 

What do you guys think would be a truly fair ask in return for 5 years of an All-Star catcher who is viewed as one of the best low strike zone receiver catchers with potential of .300 type hitter

 

What could each of those teams offer in return! True fair value deal as I think he has the best big haul potential that teams would want!

Posted
Let’s play for fun…. With those 3 teams mentioned let’s take Jansen out of the equation and add Kirk.

 

What do you guys think would be a truly fair ask in return for 5 years of an All-Star catcher who is viewed as one of the best low strike zone receiver catchers with potential of .300 type hitter

 

What could each of those teams offer in return! True fair value deal as I think he has the best big haul potential that teams would want!

 

Cristian Javier

 

Screenshot-20221212-230522.png

Posted
Let’s play for fun…. With those 3 teams mentioned let’s take Jansen out of the equation and add Kirk.

 

What do you guys think would be a truly fair ask in return for 5 years of an All-Star catcher who is viewed as one of the best low strike zone receiver catchers with potential of .300 type hitter

 

What could each of those teams offer in return! True fair value deal as I think he has the best big haul potential that teams would want!

 

Kirk has 4 years remaining, not 5. Unless I am reading things wrong

Posted
Let’s play for fun…. With those 3 teams mentioned let’s take Jansen out of the equation and add Kirk.

 

What do you guys think would be a truly fair ask in return for 5 years of an All-Star catcher who is viewed as one of the best low strike zone receiver catchers with potential of .300 type hitter

 

What could each of those teams offer in return! True fair value deal as I think he has the best big haul potential that teams would want!

 

Framber from Houston. I don’t really see any other players I’d do straight up on CHC or CLE

Posted
Framber from Houston. I don’t really see any other players I’d do straight up on CHC or CLE

 

Kirk for Kwan (maybe some lesser pieces added on either side) could be interesting

Posted
Kirk for Kwan (maybe some lesser pieces added on either side) could be interesting

 

Maybe. I don’t see the upside, I’d rather just roster the catcher than the corner outfielde

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Blue Jays community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...