Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 80
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
Well...…….We know he can swim...…………..

 

Are you implying that Cubans are incapable boatwrights? That's racist.

Posted
I'm happy with this. I wouldn't be surprised if by mid-May or early June our IF is Vlad, Galvis, Drury Smoak.

 

Shatkins loves Gurriel. They might use him all over the field (our version of Marwin), but I don't think he loses playing time to Galvis of all players.

 

Vlad, Gurriel, Drury at 3B-SS-2B is what I'm expecting. If Drury learns how to hit then maybe he can be moved to 1B and Gurriel can shift to 2B once they trade Smoak.

Posted
Shatkins loves Gurriel. They might use him all over the field (our version of Marwin), but I don't think he loses playing time to Galvis of all players.

 

Vlad, Gurriel, Drury at 3B-SS-2B is what I'm expecting. If Drury learns how to hit then maybe he can be moved to 1B and Gurriel can shift to 2B once they trade Smoak.

 

Yeah I don't think we'll ever see Drury at 1st base.

Posted
They can love Gurriel all they want but if he's an 80-90 wRC+ bat with piss poor D he won't be taking playing time from anyone.
Posted

Gurriel obviously has red flags but I was encouraged by his year and career trajectory. Age 21 he mashed in Cuba. Age 22 he didn't play as he defected. Age 23 he was horrible in High A and AA, seemingly he was getting back into the swing of things. That's two years where he didn't play or looked like s*** because of the time off. Age 24 he turned it all around by hitting in AA, AAA and then the majors.

 

Defense and plate discipline are definitely concerns entering his age 25 season but if he shows improvement again he's a position-flexible 2 WAR player. Steamer has him pegged for 1.6 in 403 ABs. I'm probably higher on him than most on this board.

Posted
Yeah I don't think we'll ever see Drury at 1st base.

 

Set positions are a thing of the past. Drury will likely see time at 2b, 3b, of, 1b, dh. Assuming the bat is somewhat close to 100 wrc+

 

3b will not be vlad's alone, we should expect vlad to have a fair number of games at dh

Posted
Yeah I don't think we'll ever see Drury at 1st base.

 

With the way the game is evolving, I think we will see a very fluid roster with guys (except for the stars like hopefully Vlad, Bo, etc) playing everywhere.

 

Of course if Drury's bat doesn't improve then it won't be an option, I'm just saying if he takes a step forward then it becomes an option. He can still cover 2B, 3B, etc. Just makes the lineup more versatile. Plus it means I won't have to see Tellez play 1B, which is a bonus.

Posted
I mean as a defensive substitution or whatever - sure...but the context was that Drury would slide in as our starting 1st basemen after we trade Smoak (with Gurriel at 2nd). Starting a guy with a wRC+ of 100 at first base regularly will always be a terrible idea. Ask the Rockies how that turned out.
Posted

All this talk about Gurriels D. The conversation should be about Travis.

 

His D really sucks and his hitting sucked last year also.

 

Travis is a liability in the field. Gurriel will be fine.

Posted
I mean as a defensive substitution or whatever - sure...but the context was that Drury would slide in as our starting 1st basemen after we trade Smoak (with Gurriel at 2nd). Starting a guy with a wRC+ of 100 at first base regularly will always be a terrible idea. Ask the Rockies how that turned out.

 

I see Drury as a guy that will start 50 games at 2B, 30 games at 3B, 10 games at 1B, 10 games OF, 10 games DH - something along those lines.

Posted

Curious to see how Galvis's power translates to the dome, might help him out a little bit.

 

Also did everyone forget Travis is still on the team, DFA when?

Community Moderator
Posted
Curious to see how Galvis's power translates to the dome, might help him out a little bit.

 

Also did everyone forget Travis is still on the team, DFA when?

 

Not sure he would even be in the top 5 DFA candidates. Even in the MIF I would DFA Urena before Travis.

Posted
Travis might be the odd man out whether he turns it around with the bat, and glove, or not, since he still has options left. I don't see them DFA him, unless he sucks out loud, and they think he'll go unclaimed, and/or can't get even a lottery ticket in return.
Community Moderator
Posted
Gurriel obviously has red flags but I was encouraged by his year and career trajectory. Age 21 he mashed in Cuba. Age 22 he didn't play as he defected. Age 23 he was horrible in High A and AA, seemingly he was getting back into the swing of things. That's two years where he didn't play or looked like s*** because of the time off. Age 24 he turned it all around by hitting in AA, AAA and then the majors.

 

Defense and plate discipline are definitely concerns entering his age 25 season but if he shows improvement again he's a position-flexible 2 WAR player. Steamer has him pegged for 1.6 in 403 ABs. I'm probably higher on him than most on this board.

 

I also like Gurriel. Not as an everyday shortstop, but rather as a super-utility player who can handle every infield position. Get him an outfield glove and have him play the corners there too. Given his skill set it's not unreasonable to think he could be a league-average hitter with above-average D at 2B and maybe 3B, and acceptable D at SS, LF, and RF.

Posted
I also like Gurriel. Not as an everyday shortstop, but rather as a super-utility player who can handle every infield position. Get him an outfield glove and have him play the corners there too. Given his skill set it's not unreasonable to think he could be a league-average hitter with above-average D at 2B and maybe 3B, and acceptable D at SS, LF, and RF.

 

Did you not learn anything in the last 10 years and being a super hech fan boi 10 years ago?

 

Gurriel has way too many red flags to overcome both offensively and defensively. His likely outcomes are probably something like... 70% trash, 15% serviceable mlb player, 15% slightly above average player?

 

Hes not going to double his walk rate, maybe he can cut his k rate a bit and have like a 90-95 wRC+, but he will most likely always be terrible at defense.

Posted
Did you not learn anything in the last 10 years and being a super hech fan boi 10 years ago?

 

Gurriel has way too many red flags to overcome both offensively and defensively. His likely outcomes are probably something like... 70% trash, 15% serviceable mlb player, 15% slightly above average player?

 

Hes not going to double his walk rate, maybe he can cut his k rate a bit and have like a 90-95 wRC+, but he will most likely always be terrible at defense.

 

a 95 wrc+ bat that can play 6 positions and has speed is a very useful player

Posted
Did you not learn anything in the last 10 years and being a super hech fan boi 10 years ago?

 

Gurriel has way too many red flags to overcome both offensively and defensively. His likely outcomes are probably something like... 70% trash, 15% serviceable mlb player, 15% slightly above average player?

 

Hes not going to double his walk rate, maybe he can cut his k rate a bit and have like a 90-95 wRC+, but he will most likely always be terrible at defense.

 

That sounds pretty good for what BTS is describing, dumbass.

Posted
a 95 wrc+ bat that can play 6 positions and has speed is a very useful player

 

I am curious to see him play CF. When he showed up at ST 2 years ago, and he ran out to stand in line for the national anthem, the first thing that entered my mind was,

Who is that centerfielder?

3 weeks to ST. Whoo hoo!!!!!!!!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Blue Jays community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...