Official Fantasy Baseball Advice Thread

[Daniel Labude]

I can't believe I'm coming back here for advice after that disastrous Bellinger/Sale trade.

 

In a 20 team dynasty league, who would you take: OF Kerry Carpenter or SP Dane Dunning?

 

You should change it to "20 team redraft"

 

But to the point at hand...I'd rather have Carpenter. Probably more likely to see value over the long haul

[Brownie19]

what the f*** is wrong with Trea Turner? He must have absolutely destroyed anyone who took him in the first round this year (re-draft league).

[Stangstag]

what the f*** is wrong with Trea Turner? He must have absolutely destroyed anyone who took him in the first round this year (re-draft league).

 

My BORED team was supposed to have Trea and Springer as 2 of my staples on offense… guess I probably should’ve sold before the season started 😩

 

Also traded for both Mahle and Wong before the season…. Mahle spending the entire year on the IL and Wong having the worst year of his career by far

[connorp]

My BORED team was supposed to have Trea and Springer as 2 of my staples on offense… guess I probably should’ve sold before the season started

 

Also traded for both Mahle and Wong before the season…. Mahle spending the entire year on the IL and Wong having the worst year of his career by far

 

Rookie growing pains

[connorp]

Zack Gelof quietly at .875 OPS at 2b w/6 sbs in his first 90 ABs. Sleeper if anyone is looking for a scoop up in redrafts.

[Spanky__99]

Zack Gelof quietly at .875 OPS at 2b w/6 sbs in his first 90 ABs. Sleeper if anyone is looking for a scoop up in redrafts.

 

Well, you're 9 games under .500, perhaps you should heed your own advice?

[connorp]

Well, you're 9 games under .500, perhaps you should heed your own advice?

 

I have Ketel at 2b, otherwise I would’ve actually.

I don’t know what’s up with Tatis, if he needs roids to be good…

Probably frustrating a lot of people with his .500 OPS this last month.

I have him in most of my leagues

[FantasyNewb]

Got an offer of Cedric Mullins, Henry Davis, and Taj Bradley for Will Smith ©. Points league. Which side?

[Carlos Danger]

Got an offer of Cedric Mullins, Henry Davis, and Taj Bradley for Will Smith ©. Points league. Which side?

 

I’m taking the three for one in a heartbeat. I assume keepers?

[MikeM3]

This is just a general thought but I find people use xwoba as gospel and it's really not even when you consider present skill and definitely not when considering future skill.

[Jimcanuck]

Brag post alert.

 

What do you folks think of my lineup in an off board 14 teamer:

 

C - Will Smith

1B - Olson

2B - Altuve

SS - Bichette

3B - Bregman

INF - Calas

LF - Carroll

CF - Harris II

RF - Judge

UT - Muncy

UT - Brandon Lowe

 

SP - Cole, Burnes, Wheeler, Eflin, Bassitt, Skubal, Keller, Bobby Miller

 

Winning gets boring.

[Terminator]

Brag post alert.

 

What do you folks think of my lineup in an off board 14 teamer:

 

C - Will Smith

1B - Olson

2B - Altuve

SS - Bichette

3B - Bregman

INF - Calas

LF - Carroll

CF - Harris II

RF - Judge

UT - Muncy

UT - Brandon Lowe

 

SP - Cole, Burnes, Wheeler, Eflin, Bassitt, Skubal, Keller, Bobby Miller

 

Winning gets boring.

 

Reminds me of twisted logic ruining the fantasy thread. That's what I think of it.

[BTS]

Brag post alert.

 

What do you folks think of my lineup in an off board 14 teamer:

 

C - Will Smith

1B - Olson

2B - Altuve

SS - Bichette

3B - Bregman

INF - Calas

LF - Carroll

CF - Harris II

RF - Judge

UT - Muncy

UT - Brandon Lowe

 

SP - Cole, Burnes, Wheeler, Eflin, Bassitt, Skubal, Keller, Bobby Miller

 

Winning gets boring.

 

Stopped reading at 14-team, but I’m sure it’s a solid roster for your cute little league

[L54]

You play in any 8 team leagues Jim?

[Jimcanuck]

You play in any 8 team leagues Jim?

 

No.... does your league have an opening?

[connorp]

No.... does your league have an opening?

 

You couldn’t even cut it in a 12-teamer. Stick to LOD where half the league is active

[Spanky__99]

You couldn’t even cut it in a league 12-teamer. Stick to LOD where half the league is active

 

You mean the league that has 260 trades to date and the deadline hasn't passed yet, that league?

 

Compared to...

 

75 in BBDL

 

72 in DDL

 

54 in BORED

[connorp]

You mean the league that has 260 trades to date and the deadline hasn't passed yet, that league?

 

Compared to...

 

75 in BBDL

 

72 in DDL

 

54 in BORED

 

Misleading. I bet 25% of the teams do 90% of the trades. Also, trades that could be labeled “basically inconsequential” prob make up a good portion of trades….

Why don’t you put that energy into rooting for a bbdl comeback, dumbass lol. Bud Light boy not looking good

[Spanky__99]

Misleading. I bet 25% of the teams do 90% of the trades. Also, trades that could be labeled “basically inconsequential” prob make up a good portion of trades….

Why don’t you put that energy into rooting for a bbdl comeback, dumbass lol. Bud Light boy not looking good

 

Try making the playoffs first, minion...

 

 

[connorp]

Well, you're 9 games under .500, perhaps you should heed your own advice?

 

I should’ve. Dude tearing it up

[BTS]

So what's a fair offer for Wander Franco today? Asking for a friend, and highly respected member of the BJMB community.

[Laika]

So what's a fair offer for Wander Franco today? Asking for a friend, and highly respected member of the BJMB community.

 

Man he is probably done. It's take what you can get season.

[L54]

I don’t think I’d even move Trevor Bauer for him.

[connorp]

Man he is probably done. It's take what you can get season.

 

When will you be ready to admit you didn’t see what was coming with Zack Gelof. Way off even the almighty Oz’s radar, eh?

[Laika]

Who is Jack Gelof?

[MikeM3]

So what's a fair offer for Wander Franco today? Asking for a friend, and highly respected member of the BJMB community.

 

Depends on your team situation. If you're rebuilding then why even bother moving him but of you're win now it's different.

[FantasyNewb]

Thoughts on Kerry Carpenter? Is he just another who starts strong and fizzles out, or does he have real potential?

[jaysblue]

Thoughts on Kerry Carpenter? Is he just another who starts strong and fizzles out, or does he have real potential?

 

He's been hitting real well as of late and for power as well. When he starts, he's usually hitting 4th or 5th in their lineup.

 

I traded Dane Dunning for him straight up in a 20-team dynasty league.

 

If you need an OF with some pop, he's worth rolling the dice on. He's only 25 so that's a plus.

[jaysblue]

In a 20-team dynasty league, would you trade Jesus Luzardo for Kevin Gausman?

[Laika]

yeah