Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Old-Timey Member
Posted
Heyman

 

"The Jays remain in contact with the Cubs regarding Samardzija"

 

New dream offseason is two of Shark/Burnett/Jimenez + Drew + one of the Bakers.

 

I don't want to get my hopes up but I really want to.

  • Replies 794
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • 5 weeks later...
Posted

MLBBruceLevine

Former Cub GM Ed Lynch at opener watching Samardzija pitch . Lynch is a top talent evaluator for Toronto.

Posted
MLBBruceLevine

Former Cub GM Ed Lynch at opener watching Samardzija pitch . Lynch is a top talent evaluator for Toronto.

 

Will the Cubs be scouting Sanchez tomorrow?

Posted
Will the Cubs be scouting Sanchez tomorrow?

 

Hope not. Hopefully they look at 1 year old scouting reports and don't examine him any more closely.

Posted
MLBBruceLevine

Former Cub GM Ed Lynch at opener watching Samardzija pitch . Lynch is a top talent evaluator for Toronto.

 

AA and Beaston making it look like they are trying to add a SP.

Posted

They have multiple scouts sitting on every game, building up a scouting report archive for The BEST.

 

I wouldn't read into this development.

Posted
I get the idea that trying to despair Hoyer and Epstein won't end well.

 

Hoyer and Epstein >> Sandy Alderson (Noah + TDA)

Posted
How could you not want this guy on the team?

 

http://www.obstructedview.net/wp-content/uploads/2012/03/Jeff+Samardzija+Chicago+Cubs+Photo+Day+pK5_BDqdcrcl.jpg

 

Says the guy who didn't take him for free in the expansion draft.

Posted
It did, but obviously as a team drafting I would have preferred access to all unprotected players. Missing out on Cobb hurt.

 

So the $10 shield I spent on Wacha seems to have worked perfectly.

Posted
I dont think Sanchez for Shark is a good trade for any other team except the bluejays, we are notoriously bad at bringing up players who have had success in the minors and then groom them for the show. We dont have any player on our team right now that is a star that we have home grown. Remember all the potential stars ? Snider, Hinske, Russ Adams. You have to go back to Vernon Wells and Halladay to the last players we brought up that had success even Lawrie isn't living up to his potential. I believe there may be something fundamentally wrong with the Jays bring up and adapt these young players, D'arnaud career was probably saved by the Dickey trade. So for the sake of another ruined talent I trade Sanchez for Shark.
Community Moderator
Posted
If we're going to give up Sanchez for Samardzija, I'd rather give up a bit more and get Price (as long as more isn't Stroman).

 

You know the Rays are only trading Price if they can get an elite, major league ready position prospect (or a similarly good young MLBer), among some other scraps.

 

Aaron Sanchez probably doesn't interest them very much at all as a centrepiece.

Posted
Ya I was going to say it's Machado, Bogaerts, or bust for them.

 

I believe they had a deal in place for Taijuan + at one point, which would have been a steal.

Posted
Ya I was going to say it's Machado, Bogaerts, or bust for them.

 

Price for Lawrie (2B) and AJ Jimenez..... Worst trade ever.

Posted
I dont think Sanchez for Shark is a good trade for any other team except the bluejays, we are notoriously bad at bringing up players who have had success in the minors and then groom them for the show. We dont have any player on our team right now that is a star that we have home grown. Remember all the potential stars ? Snider, Hinske, Russ Adams. You have to go back to Vernon Wells and Halladay to the last players we brought up that had success even Lawrie isn't living up to his potential. I believe there may be something fundamentally wrong with the Jays bring up and adapt these young players, D'arnaud career was probably saved by the Dickey trade. So for the sake of another ruined talent I trade Sanchez for Shark.

 

This angle like many others on this forum is somewhat exaggerated and leans too heavily on recent Jays history. At one point we were great at bringing up guys in our system ( 1980s was tremendous ), then we were mediocre, lately not good at all. However, one could argue that just random variance and the pitching injuries of 2012 ( way above norm ) skewed our results. And one might even guess that our draft strategy of picking mainly pitchers further exasperated things. We've rarely finished near the bottom of the league ( last two years was about as bad as it ever got ). JPR seems to have a dubious drafting record, whereas AA is a work in progress that will be clear in a few years ( starting pitchers on numerous teams ).

 

King said we'd have traded both Stroman and Sanchez by now, I knew the chances of that occurring was around 1% tops. Might get a better player at mid season for a top pitching prospect ( eg Sanchez ) and we don't need to make the move unless our team performs better then most expect. So why not see if this Jays team has any chances at all and pick up a strong pitcher second half from a pretender at that time ? To me, Shark is like Rasmus, not enough of a track record of success to feel like a long term big money contract is appropriate. Can you really get to a WS with these guys in your core ?

 

The whole "ruined talent" angle is overdone, make the trade for other reasons not for that one.

Posted
If only they had traded Lind and Gose for Samardzija and Hanigan like you predicted.

 

Wise offer; FatCow would accept it!!

Posted
If only they had traded Lind and Gose for Samardzija and Hanigan like you predicted.

 

If only Vegas would allow you to bet Boston under 81.5 as you recommended yesterday on this site. Seriously dude, you post a lot

of stupid stuff on here and I don't give a f*** who you think you are. All I have to so us read anything you post about the Leafs to realize your actual knowledge is far exceeded by your rather inflated opinion of yourself.

Posted
If we're going to give up Sanchez for Samardzija, I'd rather give up a bit more and get Price (as long as more isn't Stroman).

 

They would want more than just Sanchez in the way of talent and that's without an extension. Anyway, you can probably relax, even though both sides keep revisiting a deal, mostly because no extension looks likely, Gose is the rumored prized pig. At least 2 more pieces would move to the Cubs if they ever figured this thing out. That's a big if!

Posted
If only Vegas would allow you to bet Boston under 81.5 as you recommended yesterday on this site. Seriously dude, you post a lot

of stupid stuff on here and I don't give a f*** who you think you are. All I have to so us read anything you post about the Leafs to realize your actual knowledge is far exceeded by your rather inflated opinion of yourself.

 

lol

Posted

Probably asking Gose, Tirado and Nay, with a throw in like Drabek as a project. And with AA saying that's far too much and countering with Gose, Tirado and Nolin, while insisting they also take Happ and all his salary.

 

* I mean something like the above-- not necessarily the exact names.

Posted
Probably asking Gose, Tirado and Nay, with a throw in like Drabek as a project. And with AA saying that's far too much and countering with Gose, Tirado and Nolin, while insisting they also take Happ and all his salary.

 

 

#Despaired

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Blue Jays community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...