I think CHP prevail with Marco. I remember when we let Villanueva walk for 2/10. Estrada is more accomplished for sure, but the emotion of his unbelievable starts in the post season needs to be left at the door. Id love to see him come back for the right deal, but he lives on the edge all the time with little margin for error.
He is the type of fly ball pitcher with reliance on spotting a 90 MPH FB who could easily regress from being close to this season.