2012 pales in comparison to 2014. The Dickey trade dampened the f*** out of the excitement I had over the Marlins trade, the Melky signing, and the return of Gibby. And as we all know, the Marlins trade wound up being a massive bust anyway.
There was literally nothing bad about 2014. They started off with a banger by signing Russell Martin and then blew the roof off with the Donaldson trade. And all of the little moves AA made that offseason were practically flawless.
They picked up Carrera and Kawasaki on MiLB deals. They signed Smoak to a 1M contract. They got Colabello off waivers. They made four separate 1-for-1 trades that got them Saunders for Happ, Estrada for Lind, Travis for Gose, and Hendriks for Nessy.
The amount of value over the next few years that the Jays squeezed out of that offseason considering the absolute pittance that everything cost was unbelievable. The only move that could be classified as a poor one on paper was Saunders for Happ and that's mostly because Saunders had a freak injury in Spring Training that f***ed up his meniscus and cost him the entire season. They still got Happ back the next year.
They even kept it going into the season when they had that crazy trade deadline and picked up Price, Tulo, Lowe and Revere (and outside of trading Boyd for Price, which I'd do again in a heartbeat, the Jays won all of those trades).
Between the excitement in the offseason, the crazy trade deadline, the return to the playoffs, the MVP campaign from Donaldson, the story of Stroman getting injured and coming back, and the culmination in the Bautista bat flip homer, 2015 was far and away the best year I've ever had following the Jays.