Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Terminator

Old-Timey Member
  • Posts

    22,141
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    121

 Content Type 

Profiles

Toronto Blue Jays Videos

2026 Toronto Blue Jays Top Prospect Rankings

Toronto Blue Jays Trade & Free Agent Rumors

Toronto Blue Jays Fan Guides & Resources

2025 Toronto Blue Jays Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Toronto Blue Jays News, Rumors & Analysis

2026 Toronto Blue Jays Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by Terminator

  1. What do you think of trying him out as a reliever? Seems like he could still thrive there despite a high walk rate. Not sure he has the mental fortitude for high pressure late inning work though.
  2. I feel like they are pretty stingy with their trades though. They suck but it's not because they are easy to trade rape.
  3. Tiedemann is a 20 year old pitching prospect with 11 innings higher than A-Ball. Reynolds projects for 4 WAR and has 3 years of control left. In a vacuum I'd do that deal all day every day, THRICE* on Sundays. The Pirates would probably want Tiedemann+ and they'd be justified in seeking that. I just don't think it's sustainable to be signing big ticket FAs to fill the rotation every offseason so I'd rather the Jays try and patch the OF with a trade of a C or with a bargain FA signing. We've got to start building up some SP depth at some point. *I'm using the word "thrice" again because it was such a hit last time I did it.
  4. Reynolds for Tiedemann is probably fair but at some point we've got to stop signing 20M+ starting pitchers every offseason to fill rotation holes.
  5. Greinke would be awesome simply because of his quirky personality but he looks like he's running on fumes out there. The other guys are probably better.
  6. Yeah he'd be good AAA fodder for us.
  7. Hendricks would be awesome. He's the cherry on top of the bullpen that would turn it from good to elite. I tried to see if there was something else we might be interested in. Couldn't talk myself into Gavin Sheets but I did try. That said, while it seems like Jansen is worth more than Hendricks, how much more is he actually worth? Relievers get paid bonkers numbers right now. Kenley Jansen is running on fumes and he got 2 years, 32 mil. Hendricks has 1 year 14.3 mil and then a club option for 15 mil. Since Hendricks is on the books for a lot more money than Danny Jansen, I almost think if the White Sox kicked in some cash that might be enough to close the gap between the two.
  8. The Yankees are so insufferable. Whether it's celebrating 62 or holding press conferences for naming team captains, they love the smell of their own s*** more than anyone.
  9. Get that poor bastard out of the Rockies system and maybe he can do something with that 99 mph fastball.
  10. So we face a lefty who are we sitting? Kiermaier who says he’s not platooning either, Springer, Gurriel, or Kirk? Whit also available as it’d probably be a good idea to get Espinal in vs. a lefty.
  11. I don't see why the Rangers would let us outbid them for Conforto. They are trying to spend their way into contention and the lineup sucks so they can promise him middle of the order everyday ABs. They have no state income tax and they are more desperate than us too. If Conforto is looking for a one year deal I don't see why the Rangers wouldn't be able to tack on a few more million and a player option on top of our offer to get him. If he signs with the Jays it will be based purely upon Ross Atkins' ability to put together those elite powerpoint presentations and nothing else.
  12. Yeah I think Deadpool made a good point that I don't disagree with. 1-4 is solid and seemingly durable enough that it does cover for a lack of depth at 5-8. It's kind of like having a stacked lineup 1-9 without a great bench or AAA options. If 1 or 2 guys go down you'll still have a formidable offense but injuries will hurt.
  13. White is out of options but we could stuff both Kikuchi and him in the bullpen to start. It will cause a logjam but the depth will be important and we can option Pop and trade someone like Richards or Merryweather.
  14. Did you at any point last season watch a Kikuchi start? I wouldn't blame you if you blocked it out of your memory due to the PTSD it likely caused but handing him the ball every 5 days right now is the opposite of a "set" rotation spot lol.
  15. The average team can expect to have to use 32 starts from pitchers not already in their starting 5. It's basically it's own rotation slot. Maybe we are better than average but last year we went in to the season with a very similar rotation in Gausman-Manoah-Berrios-Ryu-Kikuchi and we needed 42 additional starts outside our Opening Day rotation. Luckily Stripling soaked up 24 of those but he's no longer here. The group you listed is a collection of iffy talent (Kikuchi, White, Francis), guys who haven't gotten past AA that are probably another year away (Zululeta perhaps but moreso Tiedemann) and guys that I don't think we can rely on at all (Ryu, Pearson). That's not a group of guys that I'd want to bet on to cover the #5 spot (~30 starts) in addition to whatever is needed to cover in case of injury.
  16. Siddall caught 73 games in the big leagues and was ass. If anything I think that experience is clouding his judgment and he's overestimating those things and assigning more importance to the position than he should. Because he was so terrible he really can't point to anything he did and say he was good, but he can speak to this vague notion that "game calling" is some magical talent and he did have that he was just bad at the other stuff! And no one can disprove it because it isn't real.
  17. Keeping all 3 Catchers should only be done if we aren't getting 80-90 cents on the dollar for Jansen. 1. He's only got 2 years left, so the longer we wait to trade him, the closer we are to losing him in FA, thus losing the catching depth which is spurring the trade to begin with. 2. Trading him for a less valuable player isn't that risky. How badly can we get burnt by losing out on 2 years of his production when we've got both Moreno and Kirk (both of whom project better) in the fold? Yeah we could be EXTRA protected in case of injury but this ignores the fact that: 3. We are thin in the OF and in the rotation. Both of those are more important than the #3 Catcher. Trading a 2.5 WAR Jansen for a 2 WAR Outfielder or a #5 SP is going to be a net improvement for the team. And it will take advantage of #1 (while we still have that surplus to actually take advantage of) while not likely to burn us (#2).
  18. What in the hell is he talking about? A Kirk and Moreno tandem isn't good enough? Lol it would be a Top 5 catching tandem in the league, maybe THE top catching tandem. Kirk and whatever MLB bum or Moreno and whatever MLB by themselves would probably Top 10.
  19. Wow Jim I thought you were better than this...
  20. Yeah I don't trust defense fueled WAR spikes like that.
  21. So is Hosmer league minimum for the next 3 years until his contract is up? No room for him on the Jays but someone out there could use him at that price I'm sure.
  22. Yeah it's fine in a vacuum but it's basically waving the white flag and saying we are going to be mediocre in LF for the next 5 years.
  23. I’d take a chance on him but I think you’re right about the Jays not wanting him.
×
×
  • Create New...