So there's a couple of factors that go in to grading these I think. First is that they should look good. Second, is that these are City Connect-themed so they need to genuinely tie in to the city.
Some of these cities are real shitholes so it's going to be tough for them. But here's how I would group them:
Genuinely unpleasant to look at:
Phillies, Pirates, Cardinals, Red Sox
Bad and failed the assignmentt:
Orioles (city is a shithole so they were fighting an uphill battle from the start), Giants, Dodgers (so lazy)
Bad but at least understood the assignment:
Marlins, Cubs, White Sox, Tigers, Mets
Mid bc of looks or city connection:
Guardians, D-Bags, Reds, Mariners, Rangers, Rockies, Astros, Marlins, Brewers, Royals
Decent but pointless:
Braves, Angels
Look decent or better AND passed the city connection assignment:
Jays, Padres, Rays, Nats