Does team building really matter to the degree this board claims it does?
Is a 3 WAR player with a defensive profile going to be worse for us than a 2 WAR player with an offensive profile?
Plus, Steamer's 3 WAR projection includes him hitting 103 wRC+ but has his defensive value at 4.7. I'm not sure how much Steamer knows about defense but that number has been over 15 the past two years. He's probably over a 4 WAR player if he hits his projections with the stick and his defense holds.
Alonso can play 1B and DH and Vlad can be 3B and 1B.
If Vlad plays more 3B I'm going to lie and tell myself that I'm fine with the 550 million dollar extension he's going to sign.
Hmm do we go with Fangraphs, the most respected baseball website in history? Or Baseball Trade Values, the junk site that people literally laughed at when they tried to charge a subscription fee?
That's a garbage take.
They want you to believe that Gimenez's WAR is all fugazi because he's a defensive-minded 2B and teams don't pay for that. Yet Horwitz's WAR is real, because teams pay for platoon 1B?
Not buying it.
I assume all you Joc (Pederson) Sniffers (see what I did there?) will love this move as it frees up the DH spot to add a DH with some power instead of Horwitz.
This is a weird ass trade.
I'm having a hard time gauging what everyone is worth.
-Horwitz could be a slap hitting DH who is essentially worthless or he could be a 125 wRC+ 1B/DH/occasional 2B who makes peanuts.
-Gimenez could be a star player on a reasonable deal or he could be an overpaid defense only type that is probably worth a spot in the lineup, but is a poor fit for a team needing more offense.
-Sandlin could be a good middle reliever or he might not even be worth 25-man spot. At least he has options.
-Nick Mitchell doesn't appear to be much but a 4th round pick is probably worth something!
Just in case anyone has concerns about Gimenez's contract, keep in mind that Max Fried is also a 3 WAR player.
He just signed for 8 years, 218 million for his age 31-38 seasons.
I mean that's one way of describing him lol.
He put up 12.7 WAR the past three years, projects for over 3 WAR next season, is entering his just his age 26 season, and is under team control through 2030.
Nah Treinen is under an ever constant risk to miss whole seasons. He even threw up negative WAR his final year in Oakland. He's definitely elite when he's right, but he's rarely right anymore.
Regardless, I'm only point out his deal because you think Yimi getting a paltry 2 year deal is somehow the Jays bidding against themselves.