I want the Jays to take the side of market efficiency. If the price for retirement home talent is a PTBNL, you might as well keep all of yours and go fishing for others.
Flip it around, if someone like Lucroy goes for DJ Davis' bastardized clone now, you might as well trade your DJ Davis for the rental. Unless the mystery player turns out to be a legit prospect, the Rockies got an absolute steal. Even if Lucroy continues to suck ass below his projections it was still worth a shot.