The problem is that if you compare Vlad to Soto you could make a case for his ask. If you compare Vlad to everyone else in baseball, it's a ridiculous ask. Soto screwed the market up.
Vlad not only has to worry about injury and his own play. He has to worry about Soto's play. Soto could have a down year and put up a 5 win season and 1 year into that contract people would be saying. Ok that was stupid. Vlad could have the identical year and be like, OK. Pay me my Soto money and it won't be there.
Tucker also put up close to 4 wins in half a season last year. If he has a great year that will effect Vlad's market.
Take Vlad at his word that he wants to be here. If Jays win this year and they are competitive in his free agent market next year believe that you can get him where ever that market is. Taking the insane risk of his financial ask this off season made no sense.