There was a lot of buzz surrounding the team in 2002, with Eric Hinske winning ROY and some young talent breaking through like Josh Phelps, Orlando Hudson, Vernon Wells and Roy Halladay. Things were looking promising.
2003: was a good season, and I admit was a fun season to watch. They had a great lineup led by both Delgado and Wells, along with a decent supporting cast. Doc won the Cy Young that season, Escobar looked like he was emerging as a solid SP (sucks he was a FA after). A lot of rookies from 2002 underperformed like Hinske and Phelps unfortunately.
2004: was a mess and that was the first season with the new uniforms. Lineup was riddled by injuries, the rotation was awful, all the BP arms JPR brought in imploded, Doc missed a lot of time as well.
2005: which looked like it could have been worse (with Delgado leaving a FA) actually wasn't that bad. The 2005 pitching was solid. Doc looked like he was in the best form that season, and a lock for the AL Cy Young, until Kevin Mench. Towers, Chacin and Scott Downs pitched well in the second half after Doc got injured, and the bullpen was solid as well. The lineup was pretty bad though.
2006: the Jays had one of the best teams under the JPR regime. They had a huge offseason, bringing in Burnett, Ryan, Glaus, Overbay and Molina. The lineup was stacked in 2006 - Glaus and Wells were kind of reminiscent of Delgado/Wells in 2003. Overbay looked like he was an emerging star, Rios finally had his breakout, Reed Johnson posted a 4.4 WAR and was one of the better leadoff hitters in the AL, Catalanatto had his best season with the Jays as well. Pitching wise, the rotation was a mess: missing Burnett for the first two months was tough, Towers and Chacin couldn't repeat 2005 and were garbage, they didn't have any depth to call upon. Defensively as well, Adams was terrible, and Glaus was a statue at the hot corner.
2007: Things weren't that great at the beginning when they had a rotation that consisted of Chacin, Victor Zambrano, Tomo Ohka, John Thompson, Josh Towers for the first two months of the season. BJ Ryan got injured which was a big blow, though they still had a solid BP surprisingly with the emergence of Jeremy Accardo lol. Gotta say, it was fun watching both Dustin McGowan and Shaun Marcum develop and come into their own as pitchers, which made 2008 look very promising of a rotation featuring Doc, Burnett, McGowan and Marcum. Lineup wise, Rios and Hill both had fantastic years, Frank Thomas was pretty solid people tend to forget, and Matt Stairs came out of nowhere. Injuries played a part as well (Glaus was banged up, Overbay broken wrist, Wells became injury prone, Reed Johnson battled injuries and sucked).
2008: the Jays in my opinion this season had the best pitching staff that comes to mind. I always said if they managed to make the postseason, with the way Doc and Burnett were pitching, they could have been dangerous. I was really excited for Opening Day that season: a rotation that featured Doc, a healthy Burnett, McGowan, and Marcum had a lot of promise. The lineup was non-existent however unfortunately (Thomas sucked, they were running out Brad Wilkerson, Shannon Stewart, Kevin Mench, David Eckstein, Rod Barajas). Overbay never returned to form. A big hit was losing McGowan and Marcum to injuries, which didn't make things look that bright for 2009 on the pitching side, especially with Burnett opting out.
2009: was a depressing year, with the Doc trade rumours, awful pitching staff. Was fun watching Adam Lind and Aaron Hill with the seasons they had, as well as Marco Scutaro. Jose Bautista had that awesome September, the Jays did get EE and Zach Stewart (who everyone was raving about) for Scott Rolen. And I gotta admit, it was funny how so many posters on here thought Randy Ruiz was the next Babe Ruth lol.
The 2000's weren't that bad as many people make them out to be and as a Jays fan, there were some good times and bad times. The Jays played in a tough era, where the AL East was dominated by both the Yankees and the Red Sox. As well, they had some bad luck with injuries and some key players underperform which definitely hindered their success at times. Overall, the fans that say 2015 was their only best year are correct to some extent, though I guess they just became fans and hopped on the bandwagon that summer. I've been following the Jays since the early 2000's, as many other prominent posters on here have, so we've seen the good and the bad. Yes there was some good, though the casuals never flocked the Rogers Centre and never were behind the team. They missed some good baseball (watching Delgado, Wells in his prime, Doc being the best pitcher of the decade), which was their loss. So for us fans who have been following the Jays, the 2015 and 2016 seasons are even more rewarding than it is for casual fans who have just hopped on the bandwagon, as we actually appreciate the current team on the field and the baseball that is being played.
Sorry for the long rant, but I hate bandwagon fans who have just hopped on board last season! GO JAYS GO!!!!