I think there's a better chance that EE stays in contrast to David Price last offseason for a number of reasons. EE won't demand a 7-8 year deal like Price was expected to get. I'm sure Shapiro/Atkins have a similar philosophy to Beeston/AA when it comes to handing out deals longer then 5 years. Secondly, EE seems like the guy who prefers to be in a place he's comfortable in, so Toronto definitely has that working for them if they send him a strong offer. He's used to the city, ballpark, clubhouse, fans etc. and he knows that the Blue Jays are close to getting to a World Series. Lastly, the market for EE won't be as large as it was for Price last offseason. EE is probably the top bat yes, though Trumbo (whose younger) and Napoli are FA's as well. I could see an AL team feel more comfortable going 4-5 years on EE versus an NL team.
Overall, at the end of the day if a team comes calling and offers 5 years for $120 million etc., EE is most definitely gone. If his market is in the 4 year range/$80-90 million, I think the Blue Jays can be competitive in trying to resign him if they're willing to go 4 years instead of 3.