I don't think anyone complained about short term FA signings or are s***ing on Atkins on a couple of FA misses. No GM is ever perfect when it comes to FA signings or trades. Atkins has been very rock solid when it comes to FA signings for the most part. However, given the issue dating back from the beginning of last season, they should have targeted FA's or trades that would have helped the lineup, rather than doubling down on defensive first players like KK or targeting a 40-year-old DH.
Should have been 4 for 4 indeed and we should be talking about 5 for 5. It's unfortunate Atkins hasn't been able to take advantage of this window.