I was going to say something like this except in a few less paragraphs. Atkins likes a high-floor profile based on contact and defense for the most part, Exceptions obviously exist but it's easier to understand why. He wants the high floor guys so they can plug and play in times when it's called for to replace big leaguers who are injured and the guys they call up won't be replacement level bums and negative WAR sinkholes in a lineup. That's a decent way to operate too when you have the financial muscle to be active in the deep end of the FA pool every year and can sign some of the bigger names (not all, obviously). Then, of course you hope your performance department can make enough of an impact to get them to at least the next level with the bat and be a true major league regular for a decent stretch of years. It won't always work, but when it does it creates a lot of flexibility in the payroll they need to be able to sign the Ceases, Gausmans, Hoffmans, and Springers when they need to.