Actually by the book you would plug them in the 1, 2, and 4 slots. Then Martin/Colabello in the 3 hole (5th best hitter) and Tulo 5th (4th best hitter).
#3 is where the 5th best hitter goes because they come up a lot with 2 outs, nobody on. Not ideal for a high walk bopper like Jose.
Bautista
Donaldson
Martin/Cola
EE
Tulo
(then 6-9 in order of talent)