Unfortunately this is true.
The first time I met Boxy I completely blacked out with rage or something along those lines. I don't remember much (anything) but I'm told I tried to set him on fire.
Using unregressed numbers to imply a platoon skill or lack thereof is a recipe to make poor decisions.
The Book's explanation is the standard but here's a nice summary:
http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/estimating-hitter-platoon-skill/
You were right about what exactly? That his OBP this year was .342 coming into tonight's game?
Well sure, but nobody said you were wrong about that. What you were very wrong about is what that figure means, which is essentially nothing. Both in terms of what we'd project his true talent OBP to be going forward and how that applies to optimal lineup construction which is what this conversation was always about, not OBP.
A) why do you seem to think getting on base is the only relevant skill for a #2 hitter?
I assume you bringing up league averages is some sort of ironic angleing on your part given the fact Kawasaki is ~30% below league average offensively.
C) thanks for self quoting your own stupidity while trying to call me out to the mods. Makes their lives easier.
The major league manager is most definitely wrong. Your blatantly fallacious appeal to authority does nothing to further whatever argument you think you have.
Fact: True talent .280 wOBA.
Fact: that's the worst in our starting lineup.
Fact: One of your top 2 hitters should hit 2nd.
Fact: the relevant citation to the accepted piece of research on this matter was already posted in this thread.
So it wasn't just in my nightmares. It's also from Davidi and Lott's book.
A relevant excerpt can be found here:
http://bluejaymusings.mlblogs.com/tag/rogers/