Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
25 minutes ago, Terminator said:

 

Pretty underwhelming season for RJ Schreck last year.  He was coming off a 143 wRC+ season in AA/AAA and looked like a potential contributor in 2026.  

It would be have been nice to get a look at Josh Kasevich last year.  He's now 26 - seems unlikely he'll ever become a solid utility player.  Seems like another Leo Jimenez (and dare I say Otto Lopez).

Posted
41 minutes ago, Brownie19 said:

Pretty underwhelming season for RJ Schreck last year.  He was coming off a 143 wRC+ season in AA/AAA and looked like a potential contributor in 2026.  

It would be have been nice to get a look at Josh Kasevich last year.  He's now 26 - seems unlikely he'll ever become a solid utility player.  Seems like another Leo Jimenez (and dare I say Otto Lopez).

I believe that Schreck dealt with a lot of injury issues last season. I think he's a very safe player to leave off of the 40 man as he's not likely to be selected in case a draft even occurs. 

Posted
On 11/15/2026 at 9:01 AM, Sorrow said:

The more that I think about it I could see Skubal being an actual option.

If he wants term and money I only see Toronto and the Mets doing it so it may come down to what organization he feels like gives him a better chance of winning. If he only wants money and a chance to win I think he’s a Dodger but I struggle to see the Dodgers doing more than a 2-3 year high AAV deal and with the CBA being an unknown this could be Skubals only chance to make massive money with term.

I think Toronto is going to make more moves than people expect and I suspect some players presently on the projected 26 man are moved. I would not be surprised if some of Schneider, Smith, Lukes, Clement from the position player side are either traded or non tendered. I do think Santander is gone, whether he’s part of a trade taking back a bad contract or DFAd after the CBA is settled I don’t think he plays another game in the Jays system. I think Keys is traded and I think there’s a possibility that Valenzuela is as well.

The Dodgers apparently want to do a Kyle Tucker sort of thing where it's low years, and super high AAV. Knowing Boras, he's going to want to beat Yamamoto's total salary ($325M), so any team willing to offer $326M or above has a shot. The question about the Mets is who actually wants Skubal? Stearns is known for not wanting to give big years to pitchers, whereas Cohen probably doesn't care. So if Cohen wants Skubal, then he's probably going to the Mets. If not, and it's Atkins vs. Stearns with the Dodgers on the outside looking in, then there's probably at least some shot. If Skubal is willing to take less years with a higher AAV, then we all know where he ends up. 

Regardless, if there's one FA who absolutely does not benefit by waiting until after the lockout to sign, it's him. He should be signing somewhere in the next 2 weeks. 

Posted

Rule 5 

I feel like they will add Perry and Guerra and that might be it? 

Stanifer is nice but is he really someone another team is going to try and roster all year in the big leagues? Kasevich, same boat. 

There is an argument for adding Schreck because he projects well. I could support them adding him. 

I would also support them trading Pinango for whatever. He's hitterish and someone else might like him but he's a corner outfield butcher without enough game power. Schreck might just be a flat upgrade. 

Posted
5 hours ago, Laika said:

Rule 5 

I feel like they will add Perry and Guerra and that might be it? 

Stanifer is nice but is he really someone another team is going to try and roster all year in the big leagues? Kasevich, same boat. 

There is an argument for adding Schreck because he projects well. I could support them adding him. 

I would also support them trading Pinango for whatever. He's hitterish and someone else might like him but he's a corner outfield butcher without enough game power. Schreck might just be a flat upgrade. 

What about Kasevich?  This guy seems like a prototypical Atkins player.  Plate discipline combined with contact.  He needs a shot at the big league roster before he ages out.

Posted
Just now, Omar said:

What about Kasevich?  This guy seems like a prototypical Atkins player.  Plate discipline combined with contact.  He needs a shot at the big league roster before he ages out.

I don't think he's likely to be selected and in the off chance he is I don't think he'd last an entire season on a big league roster. 

Posted
2 minutes ago, max silver said:

I don't think he's likely to be selected and in the off chance he is I don't think he'd last an entire season on a big league roster. 

If Clement can stick why not him?  The shine is going to wear off Clement.

Posted
4 minutes ago, Omar said:

If Clement can stick why not him?  The shine is going to wear off Clement.

He's been mediocre to downright bad in AAA the last few seasons and as such his projections are very poor for the upcoming season. Maybe he finds the right adjustment in the future to unlock a little more in game power but the present version of his bat offers little juice.

Posted
11 minutes ago, max silver said:

He's been mediocre to downright bad in AAA the last few seasons and as such his projections are very poor for the upcoming season. Maybe he finds the right adjustment in the future to unlock a little more in game power but the present version of his bat offers little juice.

He's a hit over power type guy so there isnt going to be some unlock forthcoming.  In terms of being downright bad that is just wrong.  2025 he was down with injury and 2026 he was Bisons team mvp! 

Batting .282 with 77 runs scored and a .727 OPS across 130 games is downright bad?  

Posted
22 minutes ago, Omar said:

He's a hit over power type guy so there isnt going to be some unlock forthcoming.  In terms of being downright bad that is just wrong.  2025 he was down with injury and 2026 he was Bisons team mvp! 

Batting .282 with 77 runs scored and a .727 OPS across 130 games is downright bad?  

Arguably is when it comes to MLB prospect viability. That's a league average AAA hitter and he's no spring chicken.

I really don't think any team takes him in the rule 5 unless they have a 60 on his glove 

Posted

The Blue Jays announced that they selected outfielder RJ Schreck as well as right-handers Nolan Perry and Daniel Guerra to the 40-man roster. That protects those players from being selected in the Rule 5 draft, if it actually takes place this offseason. Toronto had three 40-man vacancies, so no corresponding moves were necessary.

Posted
25 minutes ago, Omar said:

He's a hit over power type guy so there isnt going to be some unlock forthcoming.  In terms of being downright bad that is just wrong.  2025 he was down with injury and 2026 he was Bisons team mvp! 

Batting .282 with 77 runs scored and a .727 OPS across 130 games is downright bad?  

The downright bad season was the 34 wRC+ 2024 season although he was certainly held back by injury. His 2025 season was mediocre all things considered as he finished with a 101 wRC+ and his 78 wRC+ Steamer projection is a direct reflection of this. I do believe there's more raw power in the bat than the results indicate but he's yet to tap into this in game action. I still tend to believe that with the appropriate swing changes it's still possible that he can unlock more in game power but the current profile offers little to get excited about and little reason to protect him in the rule 5 draft. 

Posted
18 minutes ago, Laika said:

The Blue Jays announced that they selected outfielder RJ Schreck as well as right-handers Nolan Perry and Daniel Guerra to the 40-man roster. That protects those players from being selected in the Rule 5 draft, if it actually takes place this offseason. Toronto had three 40-man vacancies, so no corresponding moves were necessary.

I'm pretty surprised at Schreck over Stanifer tbh. It's usually pitchers that get taken. I don't think he will stick on a MLB team all year though.

Posted

Gage Stanifer is going to be drafted for his elite strikeout rate alone. Seems like a puzzling decision. A s***** team would be stupid not to draft him and use him out of the pen for a year.

Posted
7 minutes ago, Jonn said:

Gage Stanifer is going to be drafted for his elite strikeout rate alone. Seems like a puzzling decision. A s***** team would be stupid not to draft him and use him out of the pen for a year.

I don't think there will even be a rule 5 draft this year because of the lockout.

Posted
12 minutes ago, Jonn said:

Gage Stanifer is going to be drafted for his elite strikeout rate alone. Seems like a puzzling decision. A s***** team would be stupid not to draft him and use him out of the pen for a year.

I am not sure 

He must have very bad command or something 

He has been hit around for most of his minor league career and the WHIP is real rough. He was good in A and A+ last year but outside of the 100 inning stretch the results have been bad. 

If he threw 100 then sure someone takes him and tries to fix him in spring but not sure the stuff is loud enough for that 

Posted
10 minutes ago, abola2121 said:

I don't think there will even be a rule 5 draft this year because of the lockout.

I mean this is true.

Old-Timey Member
Posted

Please give me some positive news of some additions before the lockout.  Toronto sports are struggling bad right now :(

Old-Timey Member
Posted

I thought Kawhi would make the lockout less painful, but he's out (predictably) for god knows how long and I don't watch/care for the NFL or NHL. Why couldn't the lockout happen after Game 7 last year when all of us would have gladly taken a break from baseball after that heartbreak?

Posted

How do unprotected Rule 5 players work regarding trades.  Like could the Jays trade Stanifer right now or would he have to clear the Rule 5 draft first?

Posted
21 hours ago, abola2121 said:

I don't think there will even be a rule 5 draft this year because of the lockout.

I don't think there is going to be a season, let alone a rule 5 draft!

Posted
19 hours ago, glory said:

I thought Kawhi would make the lockout less painful, but he's out (predictably) for god knows how long and I don't watch/care for the NFL or NHL. Why couldn't the lockout happen after Game 7 last year when all of us would have gladly taken a break from baseball after that heartbreak?

Bring back Kawhi was a mistake. The only reason he's here is because of what happened in LA, the fraudulent circumvent of the salary cap.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Blue Jays community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...