Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Spring Training OpenerM JFL GDT: Jays vs Tigers. 1.07pm. Sportsnet


Recommended Posts

Posted

I was hoping to save my services for the regular season opener but someone needs to do this.

 

JAYS Lineup:

2B Devon Travis R

3B B. Drury R

LF T. Hernandez R

1B Justin Smoak B

CF Kevin Pillar R

C Danny Jansen R

SS F. Galvis B

DH Bo Bichette R

RF D. Pompey B

 

TIGERS Lineup:

RF R. Mitchell L

LF C. Stewart L

3B J. Candelario B

1B John Hicks R

2B Niko Goodrum B

DH D. Peterson R

CF JaCoby Jones R

SS Jordy Mercer R

C G. Greiner R

 

Pitching match ups

 

Ryan Borucki (L) vs Matt Moore (L)

 

Temperature: warm

 

Betting odds: Jays win 100%

 

Other Game Notes

- Boston suxxxxxxxx

  • Replies 77
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

Really excited that ST games start today. I have a spring in my step. Will have the game on the patio speakers as I do some work around the pool and back yard today. Makes it so much easier to do house work when you have a Jay’s game on.

 

Not interested in Travis, Morales, Biagini, Axford and to an extent Stroman and Pillar being in the mix, but really looking forward seeing all the other players during ST and regular season.

 

Love watching Borucki our ACE pitch

Community Moderator
Posted
Really excited that ST games start today. I have a spring in my step. Will have the game on the patio speakers as I do some work around the pool and back yard today. Makes it so much easier to do house work when you have a Jay’s game on.

 

Not interested in Travis, Morales, Biagini, Axford and to an extent Stroman and Pillar being in the mix, but really looking forward seeing all the other players during ST and regular season.

 

Love watching Borucki our ACE pitch��

 

I feel like you’re going to be very disappointed when Borucki ends up as nothing more than a useful 5th starter.

Posted
I feel like you’re going to be very disappointed when Borucki ends up as nothing more than a useful 5th starter.

 

You would have never drafted Tom Brady, John Smoltz or Mark Buehrle either ;)-

Community Moderator
Posted
You would have never drafted Tom Brady, John Smoltz or Mark Buehrle either ;)-

 

When Buehrle was 24 he was throwing his 3rd straight above average season. When Borucki was was 24 he was a fringy 5th starter. I’m not even sure what skills you’re seeing when you watch him that make you think he’s good.

Community Moderator
Posted
I think Biggio is going to emerge and be like a Dustin Pedroia type.. :)

 

It's hard to even think of a worse comp for Biggio

Posted
When Borucki was was 24 he was a fringy 5th starter.

 

He posted 1.7 WAR in 97.2 innings. Does that mean that he's a 4 WAR pitcher over 200+ innings? No, but I'm not sure what your argument is because I'd love to see what your definition of a "fringy" 5th starter is. Borucki's 3.80 FIP last year is better than Buehrle's career FIP.

Community Moderator
Posted
He posted 1.7 WAR in 97.2 innings. Does that mean that he's a 4 WAR pitcher over 200+ innings? No, but I'm not sure what your argument is because I'd love to see what your definition of a "fringy" 5th starter is. Borucki's 3.80 FIP last year is better than Buehrle's career FIP.

 

Obviously I don’t think Borucki’s HR/FB rate last year was sustainable. His IFFB% was actually below average. I buy him as the 4.5 to 5 ERA guy his 2018 xFIP and 2019 projections peg him as. No issue with him as a 5th starter, but this is not a good pitcher barring a significant improvement in skills.

Posted
He posted 1.7 WAR in 97.2 innings. Does that mean that he's a 4 WAR pitcher over 200+ innings? No, but I'm not sure what your argument is because I'd love to see what your definition of a "fringy" 5th starter is. Borucki's 3.80 FIP last year is better than Buehrle's career FIP.

His xFIP was 4.62 (109 xFIP-), SIERA was 4.80, SwStr 7.8%, 16.1 K%. All unarguably, below average.

Posted
Obviously I don’t think Borucki’s HR/FB rate last year was sustainable. I buy him as the 4.5 to 5 ERA guy his 2018 xFIP and 2019 projections peg him as. No issue with him as a 5th starter, but this is not a good pitcher barring a significant improvement in skills.

 

I have considered your arguments and I am awarding the decision to Metafour!

 

BorACEi!

Posted

The good news is there is a bunch of other games to watch.

 

Sandy Alcantara is looking filthy in the Marlins/Cardinals game.

Posted
Obviously I don’t think Borucki’s HR/FB rate last year was sustainable. I buy him as the 4.5 to 5 ERA guy his 2018 xFIP and 2019 projections peg him as. No issue with him as a 5th starter, but this is not a good pitcher barring a significant improvement in skills.

 

Okay, you also seem to be extremely low on projecting a 4.5 to 5 ERA on a LHP with obviously above average stuff who also throws strikes. He was just at 92 mph average FB velocity last year and his changeup is a plus pitch. His HR/FB rate might not be sustainable, but why would you be so sure that his 6.17 K/9 and 3.04 BB/9 are true indicators of talent either? That walk rate is kinda high for a kid who threw strikes all throughout the minors, and his raw stuff is MUCH better than a ~6 K/9 would indicate.

Posted
Okay, you also seem to be extremely low on projecting a 4.5 to 5 ERA on a LHP with obviously above average stuff who also throws strikes. He was just at 92 mph average FB velocity last year and his changeup is a plus pitch. His HR/FB rate might not be sustainable, but why would you be so sure that his 6.17 K/9 and 3.04 BB/9 are true indicators of talent either? That walk rate is kinda high for a kid who threw strikes all throughout the minors, and his raw stuff is MUCH better than a ~6 K/9 would indicate.

 

Because K and BB rates tend to normalize over a much smaller sample than HR/FB does. Also, walk rates tend to go up when pitchers face big league talent for obvious reasons.

Posted
Okay, you also seem to be extremely low on projecting a 4.5 to 5 ERA on a LHP with obviously above average stuff who also throws strikes. He was just at 92 mph average FB velocity last year and his changeup is a plus pitch. His HR/FB rate might not be sustainable, but why would you be so sure that his 6.17 K/9 and 3.04 BB/9 are true indicators of talent either? That walk rate is kinda high for a kid who threw strikes all throughout the minors, and his raw stuff is MUCH better than a ~6 K/9 would indicate.

 

He literally projects as a 4.5-5.0 ERA this season. I'm not sure if he has "obviously above average stuff", his swinging strike rate was a below average 7.8% with a groundball rate that was above average but not elite. His K and BB rates literally matched what he had done the rest of the year at AAA, the MLB is a different animal so expecting him to maintain his MiLB rates from the lower minors when he wasn't always young for the level is shortsighted. I like Borucki, I think he can and will be a serviceable #4/5 starter for us, but you might experience disappointment if you expect him to be consistently a sub 4 FIP pitcher.

Community Moderator
Posted
Okay, you also seem to be extremely low on projecting a 4.5 to 5 ERA on a LHP with obviously above average stuff who also throws strikes. He was just at 92 mph average FB velocity last year and his changeup is a plus pitch. His HR/FB rate might not be sustainable, but why would you be so sure that his 6.17 K/9 and 3.04 BB/9 are true indicators of talent either? That walk rate is kinda high for a kid who threw strikes all throughout the minors, and his raw stuff is MUCH better than a ~6 K/9 would indicate.

 

I don’t see the same stuff you do. Mediocre fastball, plus changeup average breaking ball, but hitters in AAA or the majors had no issues making contact on him.

 

I actually like Borucki as a someone who spends a few years contributing as a 5th starter or someone who comes in to throw 4-5 innings after an opener, but I have a very hard time seeing more than that. Who knows though.

Posted
His xFIP was 4.62 (109 xFIP-), SIERA was 4.80, SwStr 7.8%, 16.1 K%. All unarguably, below average.

 

So...just like Buehrle throughout his entire career LOL?

 

I'm just finding this whole argument silly. He did what Buehrle did for virtually his entire career last year, but, "he cant be Buehrle"? His 97 IP sample is pointless to conclude anything on either way; but lets not kid ourselves here: the main difference between the two is that Borucki throws 5+ MPH harder and therefore should have much more leeway to get away with sub-optimal rates than Buehrle had, so its obviously entirely attainable. I'm just looking at this from a pure face-value approach: a LHP with above average velocity, an above average to plus secondary pitch, and good pitchability OBVIOUSLY has a much higher ceiling than "fringy 5th starter". Like, not even close.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Blue Jays community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...