Official MiLB/Prospects Thread

[Laika]

That 2016 top 10 is pretty depressing.

 

Great then Ouch

Ouch

Sucks

Sucks

Sucks

Sucks

Sucks?

Ouch

Decent!

Kind of sucks?

[Abomination]

somebody has an aggregate top prospect list compiled on a Google Sheet somewhere don't they? Does anyone have the link handy?

 

I suggest starring it so it'll appear and be easily found in your Google Drive in the future.

[Terminator]

Keith Law's 2019 Top 100 Prospects

RANK NAME POSITION TEAM

1 Fernando Tatis Jr. SS San Diego Padres

2 Vladimir Guerrero Jr. 3B Toronto Blue Jays

3 Wander Franco SS Tampa Bay Rays

4 Forrest Whitley RHP Houston Astros

5 Eloy Jimenez OF Chicago White Sox

6 Nick Senzel 3B Cincinnati Reds

7 Mackenzie Gore LHP San Diego Padres

8 Jo Adell OF Los Angeles Angels

9 Royce Lewis SS Minnesota Twins

10 Victor Robles OF Washington Nationals

11 Alex Kirilloff OF Minnesota Twins

12 Taylor Trammell OF Cincinnati Reds

13 Bo Bichette SS Toronto Blue Jays

14 Brendan McKay LHP/1B Tampa Bay Rays

15 Casey Mize RHP Detroit Tigers

16 Hunter Greene RHP Cincinnati Reds

17 Kyle Tucker OF Houston Astros

18 Ke'Bryan Hayes 3B Pittsburgh Pirates

19 Brent Honeywell RHP Tampa Bay Rays

20 Michael Kopech RHP Chicago White Sox

21 Keston Hiura 2B Milwaukee Brewers

22 Kyle Wright RHP Atlanta Braves

23 Triston McKenzie RHP Cleveland Indians

24 Mitch Keller RHP Pittsburgh Pirates

25 Dylan Cease RHP Chicago White Sox

26 Touki Toussaint RHP Atlanta Braves

27 Keibert Ruiz C Los Angeles Dodgers

28 Brendan Rodgers SS Colorado Rockies

29 Francisco Mejia C San Diego Padres

30 Ian Anderson RHP Atlanta Braves

31 Jesus Luzardo LHP Oakland A's

32 Jazz Chisholm SS Arizona Diamondbacks

33 AJ Puk LHP Oakland A's

34 Justus Sheffield LHP Seattle Mariners

35 Sixto Sanchez RHP Philadelphia Phillies

36 Matt Liberatore LHP Tampa Bay Rays

37 Alex Verdugo OF Los Angeles Dodgers

38 Jarred Kelenic OF Seattle Mariners

39 Nolan Gorman 3B St. Louis Cardinals

40 Jon Duplantier RHP Arizona Diamondbacks

41 Gavin Lux SS Los Angeles Dodgers

42 Alex Reyes RHP St. Louis Cardinals

43 Nolan Jones 3B Cleveland Indians

44 Chris Paddack RHP San Diego Padres

45 Cristian Pache OF Atlanta Braves

46 Adrian Morejon LHP San Diego Padres

47 Travis Swaggerty OF Pittsburgh Pirates

48 Corbin Martin RHP Houston Astros

49 Dustin May RHP Los Angeles Dodgers

50 Luis Patino RHP San Diego Padres

51 Bryse Wilson RHP Atlanta Braves

52 Spencer Howard RHP Philadelphia Phillies

53 Daniel Lynch LHP Kansas City Royals

54 Luis Robert OF Chicago White Sox

55 Khalil Lee OF Kansas City Royals

56 Luis Urias 2B San Diego Padres

57 Mike Soroka RHP Atlanta Braves

58 Justin Dunn RHP Seattle Mariners

59 Vidal Brujan 2B Tampa Bay Rays

60 Mark Vientos 3B New York Mets

61 Deivi Garcia RHP New York Yankees

62 Leody Taveras OF Texas Rangers

63 DL Hall LHP Baltimore Orioles

64 Eli Montero 3B St. Louis Cardinals

65 Matt Manning RHP Detroit Tigers

66 JoJo Romero LHP Philadelphia Phillies

67 JB Bukauskas RHP Houston Astros

68 Daz Cameron OF Detroit Tigers

69 Luis Garcia SS Philadelphia Phillies

70 Josh James RHP Houston Astros

71 Jesus Sanchez OF Tampa Bay Rays

72 Cole Winn RHP Texas Rangers

73 Brandon Marsh OF Los Angeles Angels

74 Noah Naylor C/3B Cleveland Indians

75 Drew Waters OF Atlanta Braves

76 Jonathan India 3B Cincinnati Reds

77 Nate Pearson RHP Toronto Blue Jays

78 Oneil Cruz 3B Pittsburgh Pirates

79 Will Smith C Los Angeles Dodgers

80 Logan Allen LHP San Diego Padres

81 William Contreras C Atlanta Braves

82 Joey Bart C San Francisco Giants

83 Antonio Santillan RHP Cincinnati Reds

84 Ronaldo Hernandez C Tampa Bay Rays

85 Zack Brown RHP Milwaukee Brewers

86 Griffin Canning RHP Los Angeles Angels

87 Austin Riley 3B Atlanta Braves

88 Sean Murphy C Oakland A's

89 Daulton Varsho C Arizona Diamondbacks

90 Peter Alonso 1B New York Mets

91 Miguel Amaya C Chicago Cubs

92 Peter Lambert RHP Colorado Rockies

93 Kristian Robinson OF Arizona Diamondbacks

94 Shane Baz RHP Tampa Bay Rays

95 Hans Crouse RHP Texas Rangers

96 Mason Denaburg RHP Washington Nationals

97 Andres Gimenez SS New York Mets

98 Carter Kieboom SS/2B Washington Nationals

99 Ronny Mauricio SS New York Mets

100 Lucius Fox SS Tampa Bay Rays

[Terminator]

Leaving Danny Jansen off your top 100 might be the dumbest ranking of the year.

[Jimcanuck]

Carter Kieboom @ #98 seems right

[P2F]

I'm not including that abortion with the aggregate rankings.

[Terminator]

I think we should! It's paid content and it's only 1 out of 6 rankings, it won't affect it THAT much. We should add Sickels stuff too when he comes out with his. Up to you guys though.

[Laika]

It's no worse than some of the other lists, honestly.

[Boxcar]

I'm not including that abortion with the aggregate rankings.

 

Keith Law is like that guy who picked Ohtani over Trout in a hypothetical fantasy draft while Ohtani was still in Japan. He's basically just an attention whoring troll who tries too hard.

[P2F]

Kyler Murray is going to the NFL combine on Feb. 26th.

 

It appears he is almost surely choosing football over baseball at this point.

[King]

Fangraphs Blue Jays list is dropping tommorrow, I think.

[Laika]

Fangraphs Blue Jays list is dropping tommorrow, I think.

 

Can't wait to see how many 45-55 FVs we have!!!

[John_Havok]

Can't wait to see how many 45-55 FVs we have!!!

 

I'm gonna say..... 37

[Rusty_Savage]

Kyler Murray is going to the NFL combine on Feb. 26th.

 

It appears he is almost surely choosing football over baseball at this point.

 

It will probably depend where he's picked. I read an article the other day that said he's pretty much a lock to not go in the top 20. There has to be a point be slips to where baseball is the better financial decision for him

[Krylian]

It will probably depend where he's picked. I read an article the other day that said he's pretty much a lock to not go in the top 20. There has to be a point be slips to where baseball is the better financial decision for him

 

Kinda hope he gets shafted on both sides. I don't like wishy washy f***ers.

[Spanky__99]

Kinda hope he gets shafted on both sides. I don't like wishy washy f***ers.

 

It's not possible... he has that money signed, in the MLB.

[Laika]

McLogenhagen confused Waguespack with Winckowski

 

"Winckowski was added to the 40-man this offseason and we may see him in a relief role next year. He sits 90-94 and has an above-average slider."

 

The list is a bit different. https://blogs.fangraphs.com/top-34-prospects-toronto-blue-jays/

[glory]

Kinda hope he gets shafted on both sides. I don't like wishy washy f***ers.

 

I hope he picks baseball. Even if he ends up being a bust, MLB benefits from having the best athletes choose them over the NFL. If Murray chooses baseball and ends up being good, then even better for the league.

[P2F]

Regarding the lack of discussion on the FanGraphs Blue Jays top prospects list, is it correct to assume that it's a bad list and that they should probably feel bad too?

[Laika]

They are as down on Warmoth as we were!

[Laika]

The Alejandro Kirk writeup is the best.

[P2F]

They are as down on Warmoth as we were!

 

I feel like they forgot the following guys exist: David Paulino (or has he exhausted rookie eligibility?), Josh Winckowski, Santiago Espinal, Andrew Sopko, Brock Lundquist, and Cullen Large. All are worth mentioning.

[Terminator]

Todd was ahead of the curve on Alford. This totally vindicates him.

 

Todd is like a more autistic/smarter Tercet.

[Brownie19]

Regarding the lack of discussion on the FanGraphs Blue Jays top prospects list, is it correct to assume that it's a bad list and that they should probably feel bad too?

 

meh - you guys ruined prospect lists for me. There's no point in reading others now.

[tercet]

They are as down on Warmoth as we were!

 

And they said be careful IRT to Pearson, while you idiots are stuck in OMFG 100mph WTFBBQ, while bashing me for saying that same thing that FG said, I guess they are morons like me too bc they disagree with you?

Edited February 8, 2019 by tercet
butnahhhhhhh

[tercet]

todd was ahead of the curve on alford. This totally vindicates him.

 

Todd is like a more autistic/smarter tercet.

 

tyvm

[Daniel Labude]

Regarding the lack of discussion on the FanGraphs Blue Jays top prospects list, is it correct to assume that it's a bad list and that they should probably feel bad too?

 

I didnt see Noda so

[Laika]

And they said be careful IRT to Pearson, while you idiots are stuck in OMFG 100mph WTFBBQ, while bashing me for saying that same thing that FG said, I guess they are morons like me too bc they disagree with you?

 

They ranked him 4th (same as us), put an 8 on his fastball, and said that he's probably a right-handed Aroldis Chapman but could be a frontline starter.

 

Our 50th percentile outcome was basically "closer or something like Brandon Morrow".

 

I'm not really sure why you are such a loser but it's entertaining so please continue to suck.

[L54]

They ranked him 4th (same as us), put an 8 on his fastball, and said that he's probably a right-handed Aroldis Chapman but could be a frontline starter.

 

Our 50th percentile outcome was basically "closer or something like Brandon Morrow".

 

I'm not really sure why you are such a loser but it's entertaining so please continue to suck.

 

Holy rekt

[Olerud363]

Todd was ahead of the curve on Alford. This totally vindicates him.

 

Todd is like a more autistic/smarter Tercet.

 

That pretty much nails it. Tercet sounds real outgoing, goes to games, from what I hear he chats with the players parents, finds out inside info, see's things as they happen, Todd on the other hand is pure numbers, no emotion. Just raw numbers from a couple of hundred prospects and pairs it down to a top 100.

 

I wonder if they will ever team up and write a column together, they could compliment each other nicely.