GDT(1/4): Toronto Blue Jays @ Oakland Athletics - Dickey vs. Gray - 9:05 PM ET

[guylaroche5]

o m g melky

[saskjayfan]

come on texas

[Jonzo]

f*** off O's

[Chappy]

Honestly, if we win by one, it will be a replay from the 2nd inning. The reason I believe the protest will be successful is because if the catcher knew Kawa was out, he would have tagged Encadwin.

 

Jays have to win by two or more to negate the protest. Unless they lose the game of course.

[John_Havok]

This will be interesting if the protest ends up being heard.

 

I mean, I get what Melvin is pissed about, his catcher made a decision not to tag Edwin because the ump signalled Muni safe from the tag so as far as he knew, it was a force play. So if the call was wrong, why should it cost the a run?

 

Flip side, since the call was reversed, you can't call the play dead, so the result of the play as it happened seems to be correct.

 

Is this the first time a manager has challenged one of his own players from being safe to out?

[Atothe]

I do not like watching R.A. Dickey throw a baseball.

 

watch the way you talk about our ACE like that

[Orgfiller]

That was pretty fugly Edwin...

[Jonzo]

Lol route there EE

[eastcoastjaysfan]

Gibbons deserved that for playing Edwin in LF...

[bluebird]

edwin rofl

[Anemic0ffense]

Omg EE is disaster out there

[John_Havok]

There you go Wilner, now will you shut up about people that don't want Edwin in LF?

[Candy Maldonado]

oh s***

[eastcoastjaysfan]

This better be the last game Edwin plays in left.

 

Completely retarded move.

[closetjaysfan]

reality check 1

Edwin experiment 0

[DH12]

EE badly misplayed that one

[Atothe]

good god that was ugly

[Jimcanuck]

I do not like watching R.A. Dickey throw a baseball.

 

enjoyed watching Niekro and Hough throw knucklers.... Dickey is like a f***ing slo pitcher

[bluebird]

its knuckle ball time

[HERPDERP]

I hope that ends the E5 in left field experiment.

[TheHurl]

Why would this cause a brawl?

 

Have you watched latino ball players (thinking Machado, ManRam here)? It's usually at first base where I've seen it happen where the player doesn't go to the bag he tags instead but it's kind of this thing where if you don't need to tag you are somehow disrespecting the runner by tagging him.

[Chappy]

Oh boy.

[saskjayfan]

okay...Edwin I get...but how did gose take such an awful route to that ball

[eastcoastjaysfan]

And that's what happens.

 

This one is on Gibby.

[intentional wok]

Edwin in LF. Worked out yesterday, bit them now.

 

Ugh... Gose.

[guylaroche5]

well at least if lind is injured we can move EE back

[saskjayfan]

Colby would have had that one

[Anemic0ffense]

Circus is in town in the outfield

[closetjaysfan]

That looked like it should have been melkys ball

[eastcoastjaysfan]

ROFL What a gong show.