These moves are pretty to criticize in hindsight, but there was simply no way that the Jays were going to be trading Happ or Osuna when they were still trying to compete. When you add on the extenuating circumstances, especially in the case of Osuna the return was easier to justify. Let's say Osuna doesn't get accused of spousal abuse and suddenly the return is much better. All things considered getting back Giles was a reasonable return, it's too bad his elbow was acting up right before the deadline. The Happ trade though is pretty hard to justify the garbage return for a rebuilding team, some lottery ticket prospects at least would have had the opportunity to turn into something down the road.