Why can't we all just agree that pitchers should be evaluated based on a number of factors? Most of the evaluation should come from the various stats we have available to us (and we should acknowledge that no one single stat is perfect), mixed in with some visual assessments to help prove or disprove what the stats suggest are true?
I think if we do that, we realise that Hutchison has not pitched well this year; however, on top of that, he's also been a bit unlucky (we should all acknowledge there's a lot of luck involved in baseball). Can he make adjustments and go on a tear in the second half like he did last year (when he apparently made an adjustment on how he was throwing his slider)? I sure hope so.