Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Brownie19

Old-Timey Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    20,085

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    31

 Content Type 

Profiles

Toronto Blue Jays Videos

2025 Toronto Blue Jays Top Prospects Ranking

Toronto Blue Jays Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits

Guides & Resources

2025 Toronto Blue Jays Draft Pick Tracker

News

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by Brownie19

  1. Brownie19
    I'll bite, ignore Bonds/Clemens and ask: 1. How do you put McGriff on, but not Walker or Edmonds? 2. How do you put Hoffman on there, but not Billy Wagner?
  2. Brownie19
    I think this would also be my list....although I would cheat and add Larry Walker too. It's kinda funny - I wanted to kick Piazza off the list until I realised he actually graded out as a solid defensive catcher (which I never would have guessed - anyone know if he was a good framer???) How on earth does Mussina not get in? 270 wins, 82.2 WAR pitching through the heart of the steroid era? He was unreal and retired coming off a 20-9, 4.6 WAR season......was there a reason for that? I kinda forget.
  3. Brownie19
    I heard he had a beer once too. He's totally dropped in my books.
  4. Brownie19
    Clemens an ass? kinda hard to imagine.
  5. Brownie19
    Given all the injuries Griffey had later in his career, am I the only one who thinks there's a decent chance JR dipped into the PED use (like so many others) to help speed up the recovery times? I don't necessarily understand how some people can be so firm on their suspicions of one player, but not another (enough to decide to vote for one but not the other).
  6. Brownie19
    Well you're obviously a "use of PEDs or suspicions of PED use = no HOF"........my point was these two players both played 15 seasons, both put up about 80 career WAR and were both fantastic baseball players. One gets the most votes of all-time. The other still isn't in the HOF. This concept also isn't that difficult.
  7. Brownie19
    Can I ask why if you don't think Edmonds had a HOF career? Edmonds - 64.5 WAR Sheffield - 62.1 WAR
  8. Brownie19
    So awesome - although I don't remember having to fight in every tag play
  9. Brownie19
    I'll say no. Unfortunately.
  10. Brownie19
    Ok....and they both were amazing for thier first 12 years....Griffey gets most votes of all time and Bagwell still isn't in. Stupid.
  11. Brownie19
    Could just be stupidity. Edmonds was a beauty. HOFer in my books
  12. Brownie19
    And Bagwell had 72.9 WAR in his first 12 seasons. What on earth is your point?
  13. Brownie19
    It's a beautiful place...perfect really. GD - very jealous you got to play at Doubleday. Our team talked about it for years, but decided it was going to be too difficult to organize.
  14. Brownie19
    Griffey gets the most votes of alltime - Bagwell had more WAR....I never would have guessed that...
  15. Brownie19
    When is Doc on the ballet? He just lite up Twitter saying Bonds and Clemens shouldn't get in...
  16. Brownie19
    I still love emulating his unique swing...a beauty
  17. Brownie19
    I don't get it...if you're going to vote Piazza in - how do you not vote Bagwell in? Bags was far superior...he needs to get in.
  18. Brownie19
    ^this....I would suspect they are using Griffeys vote to give support to guys like Edgar, Big Mac, Walker, Wagner (who's as good as Hoffman), etc. the stupidity is in the rules set (max 10 picks), not the voter...
  19. Brownie19
    Add the guys who voted for Garrett Anderson, Jason Kendall and Mike Sweeney...
  20. Brownie19
    Beckett's a nice name. Good pitcher too.
  21. Brownie19
    Option 2 gives me a massive boner
  22. Brownie19
    You al so need to factor in how many starts your #6 starter is goingt o make. Under this scenario, the #6 starter - he does not exist. Fail.
  23. Brownie19
    Have you seen the Jays defence? Outside of Jose in RF...it's awesome
  24. Brownie19
    Whoa...2 valid, solid posts in the same thread? New Years resolution?
  25. Brownie19
    Ya - 5+ WAR in only 91 games...drool
×
×
  • Create New...