Then I'd go with:
Buerhle
Hutch
Stro show
Buerhle/Hutch pitch on the road against Tigers, stro/buerhle would pitch home games and hutch in the 5th game if needed on the road.
How many second basemen have we seen this year? We need a legit 2B who can hit for avg (or I guess 3B but I'm not in favour of moving Lawrie). Also some stability in the BP would be nice, combined might still cost less than a starter... With a fresh start, Brandon Morrow might still be the added arm we need for the rotation this year.
Relax, it was just a series of ridiculousness that made for an amazing moment in baseball that one needs to appreciate as entertainment as that is what this game is about, entertainment.
No and we shouldn't be, if he regresses that far than that's that but if he hits .240 that's actually improving his batting average, I don't know if his OB will dip that low, maybe team average or little less.