So most managers would play a DH in left, play a back-up catcher at DH, risk his DH's health by playing him at first to get said back-up catcher in the lineup, not use his best relievers in the tightest spots, etc?
His managing has improved since the trades because the roster is so dummy proof that even Gibbons won't be able to use Ryan Tepera in a high leverage spot, or put Colabello in LF, and so on because the roster/lineup/pen basically writes itself. When he actually had to think to get wins, he was clueless.
I'm not saying to get Dusty Baker for "veteran leadership" or whatever you guys accuse anti-Gibby folk of wanting. Just get a guy that knows who his best players are when he doesn't have a f***ing all-star team out there and I'll be happy.