Except Dickey was mid 30s and a knuckleballer. It's hard to gauge how well that would have translated into fulltime AL pitching with a DH. If this was a trade for a pitcher in his prime, let's say 28 with already 4 years of proven success in the majors I think I would have been way happier. But it was for a knuckleball pitcher with limited AL exposure. That's the problem, we're not saying the idea of going after a cheap/controlled pitcher was the problem it was WHO they went after. With the package they gave up, they easily could have gotten a younger AL ace, TD/Thor were well known prospects in the game.