Prelude
The Blue Jays look like f***ing garbage. It's not fun to watch. It's practically miserable.
However...
Let's take a step back for a minute from the emotions of all of these horrific games to look at the big picture for a second.
I took a deep dive into the Jays remaining schedule and ranked their remaining opponents into some fairly arbitrary buckets using current win-loss records (actual win percentage), and then I did it all over again using each team's expected record (based on run differential).
The "strength" buckets where each remaining Blue Jays opponent falls into are as follows:
- "Elite" | Teams in that .570 win-rate range and higher. These teams already look like they're serious contenders for division titles.
- "Contenders" | Teams under the top tier all the way down to teams around 5 games under .500. This is the bulk of the wild card race.
- "Bad" | Teams more than 5 games below .500. These guys are quickly watching their post-season hopes fade away.
- "Trash" | Teams at a win rate of .420 or below (>10 games under .500). These teams are already thinking about next year's #1 draft pick.
On with the breakdown.
Remaining Opponents Ranked By Actual Win-Rate
36 games remaining against elite teams:
12x Rays, 10x Red Sox, 4x White Sox, 4x Indians, 3x Athletics, 3x Mets
19 games remaining against contenders:
7x Yankees, 6x Mariners, 4x Angels, 2x Nationals
11 games remaining against bad teams (sub .460 win-rate):
6x Tigers, 3x Royals, 2x Marlins
29 games remaining against garbage teams (sub .420 win-rate):
19x Orioles, 7x Twins, 3x Rangers
Remaining Schedule Ranked By Expected Win-Rate (Pythag)
16 games remaining against elite teams:
12x Rays, 4x White Sox
35 games remaining against contenders:
10x Red Sox, 7x Yankees, 4x Indians, 4x Angels, 3x Mets, 3x Athletics, 2x Marlins, 2x Nationals
19 games against bad teams (sub .460 expected win-rate):
7x Twins, 6x Mariners, 3x Royals, 3x Rangers
25 games against trash teams (sub .420 expected win-rate):
19x Orioles, 6x Tigers
Analysis:
For those that trust actual record over expected record, the Blue Jays have
- 55 games remaining against mediocre to great teams.
- 40 games remaining against bad to abysmal teams.
This means 42% of the remaining schedule is against teams that suck.
For those that trust expected record over actual record, the Blue Jays have
- 51 games remaining against mediocre to great teams.
- 44 games remaining against bad to abysmal teams.
This means 46% of the remaining schedule is against teams that suck.
Based on actual record, the Blue Jays currently fall into that fringe contender bucket with a .500 win-rate, at 33-33. Conversely, looking at run differentials and expected win-rate, the Blue Jays look like a borderline elite team with a .576 expected win-rate and a 38-28 expected record. Now, we know why the Jays aren't close to their pythag record and that's because they have a bad manager and a terrible bullpen, resulting in an abysmal record in close games.
The remaining schedule does give the Blue Jays some breathing room throughout the remainder of the season but they absolutely have to start playing to the level that their expected record indicates. This means they can lose a few games to the truly elite teams (Rays and White Sox) but must begin outplaying the other teams in their bucket. Furthermore, they have to dominate the bad teams.
Unfortunately, they've likely already lost too many close games to be serious contenders for a division title, barring a horrific collapse by the Rays. Their most realistic hope is to grab a wild card spot. While you'll likely need 93-94 wins to have a somewhat safe chance to get into the playoffs, let's just look at 90 wins as a target for now.
This is one potential path they can take to get to 90 wins:
- 07-09 for a .438 win rate against the elites (Rays, White Sox)
- 20-15 for a .571 win rate against teams in their tier (Red Sox, Yankees, Indians, Angels, Mets, A's, Marlins, Nationals)
- 12-07 for a .652 win rate against bad teams that aren't contending (Twins, Mariners, Royals, Rangers)
- 18-07 for a .720 win rate against s*** teams that look like the worst in the league (Orioles, Tigers)
Unless the Blue Jays choke away games to the bad teams or somehow come out and dominate the Rays in their remaining matchups, their season will be made or broken based on what they do in that second tier. It consists of the highest number of games remaining and also includes all the teams fighting for their spot in the postseason.