I think there was a third path which was to simply plug holes with small payroll increases or by shifting salary away from the bullpen and try to win with the same core. In that play, you address catcher (which they did), address 2B (which they didn't), get an OF and an IF for the bench at least one of which is a solid right-handed platoon bat (nope), bring in a second tier second pitcher (still might sign Capuano but I doubt it).