Also there was a very interesting argument between Wilner and a caller that wanted Bautista on the DL.
The caller tried to make the following argument -
1. Jose Bautista is not slugging very high with his bad shoulder (caller provided data that Jose only has .420 slugging with bad shoulder.)
2. Yes Jose is getting on base
3. But Smoak can provide defense and .400 slugging at first for 15 days.
4. After the 15 days Jose can return with a good shoulder, play the outfield and provide .500 slugging for the next 100 games.
Wilner was having none of it, he brought out all his sarcasm and smugness.
Wilner - No. You don't take Jose Bautista out of the line-up for Justin Smoak.
Caller - But what I'm saying Mike is that Jose needs a rest, his power is down, Edwin would get a rest too. We wouldn't lose much over 15 games, then we'd have a healthy Jose for the rest of the year.
Wilner - No. You don't take Jose Bautista out of the line-up for Justin Smoak.
Caller - But Mike, his power is down. I think it will come back if he gets a rest.
Wilner - Well, yes (grudgingly) I admit he's not the 50 homer Jose Bautista anymore, but he is still getting on base, he still drives in runs. He's still got an .800 OPS.
Caller - But Mike!!! I think if he gets a rest he will be back to 35 homer, .900 OPS Jose. That;s all I'm saying. It's only 15 games. And he will back at full power.
Wilner - No! You don't take Bautista our of the lineup for Justin Smoak