Ironic how when advanced metrics don't fit your narrative, you toss them aside. Though in every other case, advanced metrics when used to evaluate players are considered the Bible around here.
Yes Berrios outperformed his FIP to a large degree in 2024, but to expect him to continue to outperform his FIP as he ages and other numbers like K/9 dip, looks to be a recipe for disaster.
Look I'm a Berrios fan. I do agree he's a valuable arm since he's durable and can provide innings, and there is value in that despite the non flashy numbers. Kind of the same when RA Dickey and Mark Buehrle were here from 2013 to 2015. You could rely on them to take the ball every fifth day and give you innings. If Berrios can return to his 2023 form, the better it is for the Jays and for the outlook of his contract. If we see Berrios where he barely cracks a 7 K/9, I'm concerned. Better hope he continues to outperform his FIP or else.