Basically nobody on this forum was completely right or wrong. Some people were right that complaining about the Varsho trade and IKF signing were way overblown. Others were right that the offense wasn't good enough. But were wrong about why it wouldn't be good enough: the secondary offense has been very, very good and the biggest culprits for the limp dick offense have actually been Vlad, Bo, Springer, and Kirk. They were right about Atkins having failed, but wrong about why: it's not that he overemphasized defense, but rather that he either misevaluated the core or hired an inept staff that failed to unlock their skills (both?).
And then basically everyone on the forum was wrong about the pitching.